For decades, Americans have looked to the federal government for advice on which vaccines their children should get and when. A panel of independent scientists with diverse expertise provided those recommendations following long-standing public health principles, usually after months or even years of careful review of the evidence.

On Jan. 5, in a move extraordinary for its disregard for this process, Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and political appointees at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention delivered a new vaccine schedule that shrank the number of diseases U.S. children would be protected against by one-third.

The changes appear to be limited in their impact, at least in the short term. The six vaccines dropped from the routine schedule are still available to all children with a health care provider’s approval. And immunization requirements for entry into day care and schools rest with states, not the federal government.

more to come?

Still, Kennedy and his allies appear to be laying the groundwork for an entirely new approach to immunization, one that prizes individual autonomy and seeks to limit vaccines based on personal preference rather than scientific expertise and established benefit.

“I don’t think this will be the last of the big changes we’re going to see,” said Dr. Anne Zink, an emergency room physician at Mat-Su Regional Medical Center in Palmer, Alaska, and a former health officer for the state.

The previous vaccine schedule included some shots that might not be essential for everyone, in part because prevention is considered the best option in a country like the United States that has a fragmented health care system, Zink said.

She said she would have welcomed changes to the schedule, but “I’d like things to be done in a transparent, scientifically driven process.”

The new schedule cuts the number of diseases for which all children should be immunized to 11 from 17. Vaccines for illnesses like measles, polio and whooping cough are still part of the routine schedule. But for other diseases, including hepatitis A and B, rotavirus, meningitis and flu, the new recommendations advise consulting with a health care provider before most children receive the shots.

a big surprise

The announcement of the changes was a surprise to everyone who would normally have been involved in such decisions: scientists at the CDC, outside advisers to the agency, medical organizations such as the American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Medical Association, and patient advocacy groups.

And federal health officials hinted at more changes to come.

Currently available vaccines have all been extensively tested in clinical trials and have been administered to millions of children. But the federal officials, falsely claiming that such studies were never conducted or were inadequate, said they planned to probe the timing and safety of the shots, as well as of specific ingredients like aluminum salts, which have been used in vaccines for nearly a century to enhance immune response.

“I think this is going to be a really huge year,” Del Bigtree, a prominent anti-vaccine activist, said on his podcast this month.

The new schedule is “a massive, gigantic step for humanity,” Bigtree said. But, he added, “It’s not everything I ever dreamed.”

Vaccines for measles, chickenpox and human papillomavirus are still recommended under the new schedule, which he said his audience might find “infuriating.” He hinted at “private, secret meetings” being held about more changes.

Bigtree and other Kennedy allies have recently suggested that people may now directly sue vaccine manufacturers — who have for decades been shielded from liability — if they believe they were harmed by vaccines that are no longer routinely recommended.

Before 1986, when the liability protection program was established, a profusion of such lawsuits nearly drove manufacturers out of business.

Andrew Nixon, a spokesperson for the Department of Health and Human Services, said, “We don’t comment on speculative policy decisions,” adding that all vaccines would continue to be covered by the liability program.

The announcement of the revised schedule drew immediate condemnation from dozens of public health and medical groups.

Anger arises

On Jan. 9, more than 200 organizations urged Congress to “investigate why the schedule was changed, why credible scientific evidence was ignored and why the committee charged with advising the HHS secretary on immunizations did not discuss the schedule changes as a part of their public meeting process.”

Breaking with decades of partnership with the CDC, the American Academy of Pediatrics is still recommending the previous schedule. Insurance companies have also pledged to follow the earlier schedule through the end of this year.

Since he became health secretary, Kennedy has steadily emphasized his distrust of vaccines. He fired all 17 members of the federal vaccine advisory committee and replaced them with several members who share his skepticism.

In early December, a directive from President Donald Trump urged Kennedy to align the childhood vaccination schedule in the U.S. with those of peer countries like Denmark, Germany and Japan. Kennedy responded: “Thank you, Mr. President. We’re on it.”

They were. On Dec. 18, Jim O’Neill, the CDC’s acting director, met with about a dozen scientists from the agency. The scientists provided a detailed analysis of the prevalence of vaccine-preventable diseases, the benefits from vaccines and the differences between the United States and other countries.

O’Neill, according to a health official with knowledge of the events, asked good questions and seemed to appreciate the answers, leaving the scientists hopeful that he would not make any rash decisions.

But the day the new schedule was announced, the official said, the agency scientists realized that nothing they said had made any difference.

The schedule now most closely resembles that of Denmark, even though the two countries are vastly different in size, demographics and access to health care.

The effect seemed to worsen last year, when the country experienced the highest number of measles cases in three decades.

Kennedy has at times said the measles vaccine can prevent the disease. But he has also repeated falsehoods about the shot’s safety and effectiveness, including that it contains fetal debris and causes the same symptoms as the virus itself.

Kennedy’s rhetoric about shots not having been properly tested also appears to be gaining traction. One poll, by the Pew Research Center, found that only about half of Americans are now highly confident that childhood vaccines have been adequately tested and shown to be safe.

Not all the changes in the vaccine schedule have caused consternation among public health experts. The schedule drops recommended doses of the HPV vaccine, which has slashed the cervical cancer rate in girls and women, to one shot from the previous two.

false claims

Kennedy, who has benefited financially from lawsuits against the vaccine’s manufacturer, Merck, has incorrectly claimed that the vaccine increases the risk of cervical cancer.

But before its former members were dismissed, the federal vaccine advisory committee was already weighing that change. “The efficacy is so high, there’s really no clinical benefit to receiving more than one dose,” said Dr. Ruanne Barnabas, chief of the division of infectious diseases at Massachusetts General Hospital.

Experts are more worried about the omission of other vaccines. Fewer children immunized may mean pediatricians will begin to see severe dehydration in children from vomiting and diarrhea induced by rotavirus, liver damage from hepatitis, or brain damage caused by meningitis.

For the time being, however, insurance companies, states and medical groups are proceeding according to the earlier recommendations.

“Our view is that all these vaccines are still on the schedule,” said Claire Hannan, executive director of the Association of Immunization Managers, which represents state and local officials.

“They’re still recommended; they’re just not routine,” she said. “And they’re still covered.”