Four people from the South Bay and East Bay have died at Panther Beach in the past six months, and another, from the Peninsula, remained missing after being swept into the ocean last Sunday, in a string of tragedies prompting calls for stronger warnings and more patrols along the scenic coast north of Santa Cruz.
Among the myriad wonders along California’s spectacular western edge, Panther Beach just 8 miles north of Santa Cruz stands out for its picturesque beauty. On clear days, a dramatic arch in the rock outcropping jutting into the ocean at its southern end can frame the setting sun. When the tide is low enough, visitors can pass through this gap, known as the keyhole, into a cozy, sandy cove bounded by dramatic cliffs.
Panther, the keyhole, and Hole In The Wall Beach beyond — visitors generally lump them together as “Panther Beach” — feature prominently on social media. In the past few years, local first responders say, photos and videos spreading on Instagram, Facebook and TikTok have fueled Panther’s popularity. A new, paved parking lot opened this spring, making it more accessible.
But the spot’s beauty and online fame belie its hazards: swelling tides, powerful waves, and steep cliff walls. Panther’s high profile, plus its deadly risks and an often-inattentive public, produce a simple, grim math: The more people come, the more people die. Though signs warn of dangers, the spate of deaths is spurring debate about whether more could be done.
“We can only put up so many signs,” State Parks spokesman Michael Horn said, adding that some people ignore them.
The series of tragedies started in early June when 19-year-old Alexia Kuvshinikov, a first-year political science student at Santa Clara University, fell to her death off a bluff onto rocks near Panther. Two days later, San Jose State University public health student Mahial Sran, 20, of Fremont, and her friend Harshita Nair, 21, also from Fremont and a UC Berkeley legal studies student, were swept off the beach near the keyhole. Both died. In September, Claudia Renderos Rodriguez, of San Jose, was knocked by the ocean off the rocks at Panther. Pulled from the water, she died later in the hospital. Last Sunday, Se Nah Park, a 24-year-old woman from San Bruno, was caught by the tide at Hole In The Wall and swept out while trying to escape through the keyhole. The U.S. Coast Guard suspended search efforts the next day, and she has not been found.
Arvinder Singh Sran, father of Mahial, said if Panther can’t be closed, it needs a more powerful deterrent: a posted death count at the entrance.
“They should put a sign over there that this many people lost lives, so be careful,” Sran said, adding that Mahial, the “sunshine” of the family home who aimed to become a nurse practitioner, was a good swimmer.
A sign tallying fatalities may be “one of the few things you could actually do” to reduce tragedies at Panther, said UC Santa Cruz earth sciences professor Gary Griggs, who’s been taking students there for decades to study the geology.
That’s an idea that has recently come to the attention of State Parks officials and is under consideration, said Jordan Burgess, deputy district superintendent for the agency’s Santa Cruz district.
Se Nah Park’s father, Kwang Park, suggested that perhaps rangers should patrol Panther regularly to warn of the dangers and make sure everyone is out by dark.
Noel Bock, secretary of the community group Davenport North Coast Association, called for more ranger presence along that stretch of coast, including at Panther, where the paved lot with a bathroom building replaced a potholed dirt strip beside Highway 1 in April.
“If you’re going to open it up to the public, you need to supply people to patrol the area,” Bock said. “A lot of people don’t understand that tides change and they’re caught unawares. It’s basic stuff if you live on the coast, but if you don’t live on the coast, you may not understand the variety of waves and wave conditions.”
Scientist Griggs said there’s no realistic way for authorities to stop deaths by adding patrols in a region where numerous sites share Panther’s risks.
“There are so many little beaches,” Griggs said.
Gabe McKenna, Santa Cruz district public safety superintendent for California State Parks, said the district has been focusing resources on the coast north of Santa Cruz because of the increased visitation, which he said is also being driven by the new Panther lot, a project by federal and county agencies.
Lifeguards and parks police warn visitors of the coast’s risks, McKenna said. But at this time of year, State Parks has only one lifeguard and varying numbers of police to patrol a large area from Santa Cruz to a little past Davenport, with two guards in the area in summer, McKenna said.
“Having someone at each location for any given period of time would not be sustainable,” McKenna said.
State Parks is working closely with other agencies involved in coastal safety, and looking at signage, staffing, public outreach and how to best allocate resources, McKenna said.
Se Nah Park was among a group of six friends who on the afternoon of Nov. 8 walked from Panther through the keyhole to Hole In The Wall, a narrow crescent of sand bounded by sheer cliffs. They stayed past sunset, into the night, until the rush of a wave coming near them in the darkness alerted them to the rising tide — too late. Surging waves caught them as they fled toward the keyhole, battering some of them against the cliff. Se Nah disappeared into the ocean and remains missing.
Hole In The Wall has a pronounced risk from tides, since the only way out is through the keyhole, McKenna said.
In recent weeks, an El Niño-linked bulge of warm ocean water known as a Kelvin wave that came up from the south, along with warmer than usual seawater along the California coast, are creating “significantly higher” tides than usual, Griggs said. Those conditions can “move the tide quite a bit further inland” at places like Hole In The Wall, he said.
Even just walking through the keyhole from Panther can bring life-threatening danger, because it exits into a zone where waves can hit when the tide isn’t high, said Capt. Kyle Breton of the Santa Cruz County Fire Department, who responded to several of the fatal incidents this year.
And at Hole In The Wall, people can be on dry sand, and a large wave can sweep in all the way to the cliff, Breton said.
So-called “sneaker” waves can knock people into the water at Panther and many locations along the coast north of Santa Cruz that face the open ocean directly, Breton said.
“It’s not like you see a huge crest coming at you — it’s just that one wave has much more power,” Breton said.
Cecile Juliette, a spokeswoman for Cal Fire, which also responds to emergencies along the coast north of Santa Cruz, said that in recent years there have been more and more social media posts about the keyhole. “So we’re getting more visitors to the area,” Juliette said.
For the weekend when Se Nah Park went missing, the National Weather Service had warned of hazardous surprise waves and strong rip currents along the Pacific coast. But such alerts, even when spread by news media, don’t always sink in, said her father Kwang.
“The news can always just say, ‘Hey, danger, danger,’ and it just pops up so much that people probably just ignore it,” he said.
Four signs between the Panther Beach parking lot and the sand warn of hazards, from waves and currents to incoming tides and steep cliffs. On one, in an area State Parks says has cellphone reception, a QR code links to real-time information about ocean conditions and tides.
A lot of young people talk about Panther Beach, said Marie, a friend of Se Nah’s who didn’t want her last name published for fear of harassment on social media. Marie, who was with Se Nah at the beach that night, said that as the group descended to Panther in the afternoon, she didn’t notice the signs warning of the risks.
Kwang Park said he wished there were an easy way to keep people safe along the coast.
“I don’t think any bigger sign or anything would do it,” Park said. “Even if you close it, people are still going to jump the fence.”
This weekend, the National Weather Service is warning of “dangerously large breaking waves” of 25 feet to 35 feet — even up to 50 feet at limited locations — along California’s coast into Sunday. Santa Cruz County on Friday warned “extreme coastal danger” was expected to continue into Monday with a “second swell” delivering more big waves. “Do not return to the coast when it calms down on Sunday,” the county said.
The vast majority of people who get in trouble along the coast appear to be “unaware of the dangers,” fire captain Breton said.
“The trick there is being informed,” Breton said. “The ocean is extremely unforgiving.”


