

To celebrate her 25th birthday, Marie invited a small group of close friends and cousins for a sunset bonfire at picturesque Panther Beach north of Santa Cruz. The sky was clear and the tide was low at close to 4 p.m. as they made their way down a steep path to the beach, carrying firewood, folding chairs and a guitar.
The three men and three women, all in their 20s, walked across the sand to the southerly side of the majestic keyhole rock formation, one of the most photographed beach features on the California coast, framing the setting sun in countless postcards and social media posts.
They weren’t aware of the National Weather Service bulletins warning of hazardous beach conditions last Sunday, that sneaker waves and rip currents could pull them out to sea, or that news accounts last June had detailed the drownings there of two college students, Marie and one of her birthday guests said in exclusive interviews this week with the Bay Area News Group.
As her guests gathered around the bonfire, their bare feet in the sand, Marie handed out brightly-colored pens and blank pages torn from the journal she pulled from her backpack and invited everyone to express the quiet gratitude of their youth and their wildest hopes for what lay ahead.
Se Nah Park (pronounced “Senna”), Marie’s friend since kindergarten at St. Catherine of Siena in Burlingame, was the first to finish and folded her missive into a delicate origami figure of a crane. When everyone laid down their pens, they tossed their secret yearnings into the fire.
The waning crescent moon had set. The sky turned pink. The stars came out.
“I thought that would last forever,” Marie said. “I didn’t expect anything bad to happen.”
They didn’t realize that the warmer waters along the California Coast were creating significantly higher tides than normal that day, and would bring treacherous waves that smashed against the cliffs and dragged the friends apart. They couldn’t imagine that this magical birthday would end in tragedy.
For the past week, Marie and another birthday guest, Jasmine, who dislocated a shoulder in her desperate fight with the waves that night, have joined Se Nah’s parents and two younger siblings, along with dozens of friends and coworkers, searching for signs of the 24-year-old chemist from Santa Clara. The U.S. Coast Guard suspended its active search the day after she disappeared — “our deepest condolences are with her family and loved ones,” a Coast Guard news release said.
Santa Cruz County Sheriff’s Office, however, sent up its fixed wing plane on Tuesday and continued to send drones to fly along the rugged coastline later in the week. So far, searchers have only found her sneakers near the remains of Sunday’s bonfire, and a keychain that had been attached to her bag.
Since news of Sunday’s tragedy broke, comments on social media have often laid blame on Se Nah and her friends for missing the warning signs, for staying too late, for not being careful. Marie and Jasmine were willing to share their traumatic story for the first time publicly, along with their feelings of guilt and regret, in hopes that others might take precautions and not suffer the same fate. Afraid of online harassment after suffering the unbearable tragedy, they asked the Bay Area News Group to withhold their last names.
“I should have known not to come here, I should have known better,” Marie said, breaking down in tears. “Everyone’s telling me it’s not my fault, but I should have taken care of everyone. There’s a lot of should haves and could haves. But I just want her back.”
On the third day of the search, she stood on the bluff overlooking the golden keyhole rising from the sand that divides the north and south beaches and recounted in harrowing detail the experience that sucked them all into the water.
“Ever since I left the beach, all I can think about is her face,” Marie said, “and what it must have been like, and how cold, and how she’s not going to be able to spend another Christmas or Thanksgiving and do the things that she’s been wanting to do.”
Marie lives on the Peninsula and works as a doula preparing women for childbirth. She is making plans for nursing school. She and Se Nah became best friends until Marie moved away in third grade. Se Nah was a quiet, gentle soul, she said, but once she got to know you, she opened up “and couldn’t stop talking.”
They kept in touch over the years, but made a bigger effort over the past six months to reconnect.
The tide was rising when Marie asked her friends for another reflection. This time, they picked up the pens to jot down their wishes for the future. Before most of them had a chance to toss their second notes into the flames, however, a wave rushed perilously close to the bonfire. By then, the other beachgoers they noticed earlier were long gone.
“We’ve got to leave now,” one of the birthday guests said.
They rushed to collect their things and gave each other quick hugs.
“The last thing I said to her was, ‘I’m so grateful that you’ve been my friend for so long, and even if we haven’t talked in a while, I really want this to continue. Can we stay friends?” Marie recounted. “And she said, ‘yes. I really like that.’”
Marie and another friend, one of the young men, told the four others to go on ahead as they picked up the last remains of the party.
It was sometime after 8 p.m. then and the waves started coming in harder and closer. Jasmine and Se Nah, along with Marie’s two male cousins, clambered along the base of the sheer cliffs, back toward the keyhole passage to the other side.
They were about 20 feet shy of the keyhole when two waves hit. The first was enough to knock them down and plunge them into the water. As Jasmine rose from the sand, where she had dug in her hands to stabilize herself, the second plowed into her back, thrusting her into the base of the towering cliff and dislocating her shoulder.
“You can’t really see anything because you’re surrounded with so much fear,” Jasmine said, “and it’s in the dark, and it was so loud.”
She didn’t know Se Nah was gone.
At one point, Jasmine said she looked out and saw what appeared to be an iPhone flashlight glowing in the face of a swell some 30 feet out. Was Se Nah in there, holding it, Jasmine wondered? She couldn’t tell. Se Nah wore a grey sweatshirt and pants that night, matching the color of the ocean’s turbulent foam.
In the chaos, the cousins helped the injured Jasmine through the keyhole, then raced back through, calling out Se Nah’s name. They heard no response.
They tried calling 911, but had no signal from the beach, so they scurried up the same cliffside trail that brought them here. They finally reached emergency dispatchers. It was about 8:30 p.m.
By then, Marie and the last party guest also had been sucked into and spit out of the water as they made their way through the keyhole. Safely on the other side, they heard shouts from the clifftop.
“Is Se Nah with you?” they called.
It took a moment for the horror to become clear.
“This isn’t happening,” she said to herself.
She and the other party guest ran back through the keyhole to find her, the water up to their waists, to no avail. As emergency crews arrived at the beach, an ambulance took Jasmine to the hospital.
At one point in recounting her story, Marie collapsed to the ground, sobbing, “it should have been me.”
Earlier this week, Marie and Jasmine were invited to Se Nah’s church, San Jose Christian Alliance Church, for a special prayer service. Marie felt so guilt-ridden over what had happened, “I expected them to turn me down at the door.”
Instead, she said, “I was overwhelmed at how much love and forgiveness there was.”
A pastor’s wife also helped, telling Jasmine that the universe had given them a second chance, and that Se Nah would want the best for them.
Jasmine and Marie don’t know what Se Nah wrote in the note she cast into the fire that night. But they knew she’d hoped one day to buy a house and get a dog. She was looking forward to a family vacation to Osaka.
Before they left the bonfire, Jasmine noticed Se Nah tuck the second note filled with her dreams and desires into her bag.
It hasn’t been recovered.


PREVIOUS ARTICLE