Print      
Trump officials split on N. Korea with Bannon
Remarks from top general in China contradict top aide’s fiery interview
By Jane Perlez and Choe Sang-Hun
New York Times

BEIJING — President Trump’s administration plunged the United States’ Asian alliances into new confusion Thursday with conflicting signals over how to counter North Korea’s nuclear threat, as the chief White House strategist said a military solution was impossible.

Three other leading officials of the administration — its top military general on a visit to China, and its defense secretary and secretary of state in Washington — effectively contradicted him, emphasizing that Trump was prepared to take military action if necessary.

The mixed messages about North Korea policy added to the sense of disarray coming from the White House, where Trump appeared to have all but forgotten the crisis a week after he threatened an ad hoc “fire and fury’’ response to North Korea’s leader, Kim Jong Un, if he menaced the United States.

Stephen Bannon, the nationalist ideologue who is Trump’s chief strategist, said in an interview that there was “no military solution’’ in the Korean Peninsula, and that he might consider a deal in which US troops withdrew from South Korea in exchange for a verifiable freeze in the North’s nuclear program.

But General Joseph F. Dunford Jr., the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff who was concluding a three-day visit to Beijing, dismissed the possibility of a US troop withdrawal. Speaking to reporters, he repeated the administration’s earlier position that military action was not preferable but still possible.

Dunford also said there were no plans to cancel US military exercises with South Korea scheduled to start Monday — drills that North Korea could interpret as a new provocation. He called the exercises “very important to maintaining the ability of the alliance to defend itself.’’

Later in the day, after a meeting in Washington with Japan’s defense and foreign ministers that was aimed partly at reassuring them, Defense Secretary Jim Mattis and Secretary of State Rex Tillerson expressed support for Dunford’s statements.

“Our approach has been endorsed by the president,’’ Tillerson told reporters.

He said the United States and its allies would further intensify economic and diplomatic pressures on North Korea, and he praised China for its increased cooperation in those efforts.

Tillerson said he had read Bannon’s remarks, but declined to respond directly to them. However, he said the diplomatic campaign against North Korea must be backed by the threat of “a strong military consequence if North Korea chooses wrongly.’’

The deal Bannon suggested, however unlikely, would be a stunning departure from decades of US policy. Its mere mention astonished analysts in a region still grappling with the implications of Trump’s impromptu tirade against North Korea last week.

The conflicting statements compounded confusion at a time when the United States’ allies in East Asia are already nervous about its commitment to defend them, should Pyongyang acquire the ability to strike US cities with nuclear-armed ballistic missiles.

In his meetings in Beijing, Dunford has been trying to persuade the Chinese leadership, including President Xi Jinping, to get tough on North Korea.

“We have a long-term alliance commitment with South Korea,’’ Dunford said.

Referring to Bannon’s quoted remarks, he said: “I’ve not been involved in any discussions associated with reducing or removing our presence in South Korea. If that was said, I don’t know about it.’’

President Moon Jae-in of South Korea, continuing to try to assure his public over Washington’s strategy, said Thursday Trump had agreed to seek his consent before taking military action against North Korea.

In his interview with the magazine The American Prospect, Bannon said the fact that Seoul, South Korea’s capital, lies in range of the North’s conventional weapons ruled out a military solution.