Creator of Polly’s Pies dies at age 98

OBITUARY

Harvey ‘Eddie’ Sheldrake also played basketball for UCLA during the 1950s

Polly’s Pies co-founder Eddie Sheldrake stands with his daughter Sunny Martin, Polly’s Pies marketing supervisor, at the chain’s location in Fullerton in 2008. Cindy Yamanaka — staff photographer

Image

By Brock Keeling

bkeeling@scng.com

Harvey Edward “Eddie” Sheldrake, co-founder of Polly’s Pies and a former college basketball standout, has died. He passed away May 8 at age 98, according to a statement from his company’s public relations team.

The statement continued, “His vision and leadership laid the foundation for what Polly’s has become today — a beloved community staple for more than 55 years.”

Before making a name for himself in the food industry, Sheldrake made his mark at UCLA for his basketball prowess. “A fiery little guard on the early John Wooden teams of 1949-50-51, Eddie was captain of the UCLA team during his senior season,” according to the UCLA Bruins Hall of Fame website. “Eddie was named to the 1951 All-Conference team and was twice named to the ‘Little All-American’ team.” He went on to lead the Bruins in shooting percentage in 1950 and ‘51 “and also set a UCLA record with his 38-point effort against Stanford in 1951.”

Sheldrake, a Los Angeles native who served in the U.S. Navy, was inducted into the UCLA Athletics Hall of Fame in 2000; he also played for the Amateur Athletic Union and in the National Industrial Basketball League for one season in 1952-53.

Afater his basketball career, Sheldrake worked as a furniture salesman before pivoting into the restaurant realm, starting in 1966 when he and his brother, Donald, opened California’s first free-standing Kentucky Fried Chicken franchise in the Belmont Shore area of Long Beach. After opening a handful of finger-lickin’ franchises, the brothers founded Polly’s Pies, a restaurant and bakery chain known for its titular pies.

The first Polly’s opened in Fullerton on Raymond Avenue in 1968.

Inspired by the success of Marie Callender’s, Sheldrake purchased a popular pie shop, Pie Pantry, in a Fullerton strip mall. He and his brother christened their new pie enterprise Polly’s Pies because they wanted to recycle the P marquee letters left behind at the former restaurant, as well as the door handles shaped like the letter “P”.

“I was too cheap, so I had to come up with a name that had ‘P’ in it,” Sheldrake said in 2016.

Polly’s expanded its menu to feature heartier fare like sandwiches, rotisserie chicken and burgers.

Sheldrake is survived by eight children, 16 grandchildren and 11 great grandchildren, according to his bio on the eatery’s website.