Gov. Gavin Newsom’s decision to commute the sentences of California’s entire death row population feels like a shiv in my back.
The criminal justice system already had spoken through juries, judges and decades of legal appeals.
The governor failed to hear the pleas of victims or see their mothers’ tears. He turned his back on the sorrow of the fathers, brothers, sisters, families and friends of the slain. He disregarded the hundreds of juries that grappled with the value of life and death, as he ignored the sentences of hundreds of judges and the cases presented by scores of prosecutors.
Some of these killers have slain multiple individuals.
Charles Ng was convicted of torturing and murdering 11 women in the 1980s.
Ramon Salcido murdered six family members, including his wife and two daughters in 1989.
Richard Allen Davis kidnapped my daughter Polly during a slumber party in the dead of night, was convicted of attempted lewd conduct with a minor and killed and discarded her little body on a pile of trash.
When the jury recommended the death penalty for Polly’s killer, I felt that justice had been served. The jury and judge had fully recognized the brutality of the crime and the devastation inflicted on my family.
Their verdict represented accountability and closure within the framework of California law.
Our prosecutor said to me, “See, you can trust California’s criminal justice system.”
Well, you can until you can’t: The criminal justice system can turn on a whim.
Gov. Newsom justified his decision by claiming that “state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California’s values.”
However, California voters rejected efforts to abolish the death penalty in both 2012 and 2016. Those election results represent the will of millions of Californians and provide a far more credible measure of our state’s values than the personal views of a lame-duck governor.
Newsom met with Polly’s half-sister, Annie Nichol, and stepsister, Jessica Nichol, both outspoken opponents of the death penalty, at San Quentin prison last month. The sisters reportedly argued that executing murderers does not bring meaningful healing to many victims’ families.
The governor cited the “almost spiritual” moment as a deciding factor in his blanket commutation of California’s 548 prisoners on death row. While some families may find peace through forgiveness or opposition to capital punishment, others do not. Victims’ families are not monolithic and no single perspective speaks for everyone who has suffered the loss of a loved one to violent crime.
At a time when California faces serious challenges, including some of the nation’s highest utility costs, soaring gasoline prices, a persistent homelessness crisis and billions of dollars spent on the still-unfinished high-speed rail project, I question why commuting the sentences of every death row inmate became a priority.
For many Californians, this decision does not represent justice. It represents a profound disconnect between state leadership, crime victims and the voters who repeatedly chose to retain the death penalty.
If Gavin Newsom genuinely intended to end the death penalty, he had eight years and a legislative supermajority to pursue a permanent change in the law. Instead, he waited until the final weeks of his administration to take an incomplete action that seems designed to benefit his legacy rather than provide a lasting solution.
Marc Klaas is a retired child advocate and founder of the KlaasKids Foundation. For more than three decades, he has been a prominent voice on victims’ rights, public safety and criminal justice issues following the murder of his daughter, Polly Klaas, in 1993.


PREVIOUS ARTICLE