Selig takes a hit, but MLB will benefit
All-Stars won't decide home field in World Series

There was no puff of white smoke emanating from the conference rooms of a Dallas-area hotel Wednesday when baseball's new collective bargaining agreement was reached.
Truthfully, the only parties really interested in the international draft, the luxury-tax threshold and other economic issues were the league, the lawyers, a handful of media members and MLB Network, which would have had a lot of time to kill if a lockout had canceled next week's winter meetings.
For the rest of us, probably including some players and owners, the prevailing thought was “wake me when it's over.”
Now it's over. And in a surprise development, the “Selig Rule” was eliminated, taking away World Series home-field advantage from the team whose league wins the All-Star Game and handing it to the team with the best overall record.
Finally.
It's a blow to Bud Selig's legacy. The former commissioner came up with the rule in 2003 after the memorable 2002 All-Star tie when the teams ran out of pitchers.
The Selig Rule never should have been implemented for the simple reason the All-Star Game is managed like a spring training game, with frequent substitutions so every team has a representative. Nowadays, many players just want to go to the festivities and don't care about participating in the game. They're already planning their excuses for next year's game in Miami, where they can vacation with the family and not worry about their league winning the game.
Bravo to Commissioner Rob Manfred and MLB for coming to their senses, even at the risk of embarrassing Selig, who should recover by Monday, when he's expected to be elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame on the Today's Game Era ballot.
The rest of the CBA is complex and full of arcane measures meant to keep the owners and players incredibly wealthy and the playing field relatively even. The game was not broken, so there was no need to overhaul it.
Changes in things like the luxury-tax threshold and free-agent compensation won't affect fans, so we'll wait for the owners and players union to spin it after looking at the tape.
In the meantime, here are five thoughts on what happened and what did not happen in CBA talks:


PREVIOUS ARTICLE