As large regional theater companies struggled to keep their doors open in 2025, it’s been good to see so many Sonoma County theaters still very much alive and kicking. My top five favorite shows are taken only from those I reviewed for the Argus-Courier, which leaves out many deserving productions. That said, these five shows — listed in the order in which I reviewed them — were stand-outs for me in a year packed with entertainment for every kind of theatergoer.

‘Steel Magnolias’ — Cinnabar Theater

Director Miriam Ani brought together an outstanding ensemble cast to create a believable and emotionally satisfying production of an old favorite, supported by an excellent set, thoughtful costuming, detailed props and some impressive on-stage hairstyling.

‘Meet Me at Dawn’ — Mercury Theater

Theatrical newcomer Mercury’s first fully-staged production was a surprising, delicate piece by playwright Zinnie Harris about memory, trauma and grief. It left a lasting impression, thanks to Michael Fontaine’s sensitive direction, notable performances by Ilana Niernberger and Amanda Vitiello, and the beautiful half-real, half-dream space created by its talented creative team.‘I Love You, You’re Perfect, Now Change’ — Sonoma Arts Live

All four members of the ensemble cast brought strong vocals, acting talent and the ability to make the comedy zing in this slight but entertaining musical, expertly directed by veteran director Carl Jordan and featuring some impressive quick-changes costumes from designer Kate Leland.

‘The Resistible Rise of Arturo Ui’ — Mercury Theater

Kevin Bordi gave one of the most memorable performances of the year as Arturo Ui, physically and vocally transforming from a hunched, pathetically aggrieved loser to a commanding man with a terrifying amount of power. The timely, frightening message of this Brechtian tale added to the production’s overall impact.

‘A Christmas Story’ — 6th Street Playhouse

Among the many seasonal shows jostling for audiences this year, 6th Street’s delightful musical production of “A Christmas Story” was thoroughly enjoyable for adults and children alike. It was particularly encouraging to see several talented young actors on stage, easily holding their own within a large, multigenerational and experienced cast.

Originally from the U.K., Jenny Hollingworth is a freelance writer, theater director, reasonable cook, hopeless gardener, and is grateful to be living in beautiful Sonoma County.