One of the great mysteries of Justin Fields’ performance in Sunday’s 20-17 victory over the Cincinnati Bengals is why the Chicago Bears didn’t change their game plan to favor him.
When Fields replaced starter Andy Dalton, who got knocked out with a left knee injury in the second quarter, they appeared to run plays better suited for the veteran pocket passer. The offense bogged down and the Bears barely hung on with the benefit of a four-takeaway performance by the defense.
Maybe that explains why coach Matt Nagy, when asked a personnel question Monday morning, claimed it was scheme-related — meaning off limits to discussion.
Dalton had his knee examined Monday, and Nagy said he expected to have a full report by the evening. NFL Media reported that an MRI confirmed Dalton is dealing with a bone bruise, and that leaves his availability for Sunday’s road game against the Cleveland Browns in question.
Asked directly if Dalton remains the starting quarterback if healthy, Nagy demurred.
“If Andy is healthy, is he your starter?” said Nagy, repeating the question. “That’s something that I’m not going to get into with scheme.”
When a reporter objected that the question wasn’t related to scheme but rather to personnel, Nagy didn’t budge.
“Of course it is,” he said. “That’s 100% scheme. That’s 100% scheme.”
About 10 minutes after Nagy’s news conference wrapped up, a public relations official returned to the media room with a clarification: Nagy did not understand the original question, and Dalton is indeed the starter when healthy.
That doesn’t get us any closer to knowing who will start against the Browns. It’s understandable Nagy doesn’t want to tip off Cleveland’s coaching staff regarding which quarterback it should prepare for. Dalton and Fields possess different skill sets, and Fields’ ability to extend plays with his legs and turn seemingly broken plays into big gains likely would lead the Browns defensive coaches to craft a different plan.
But it’s confusing from the standpoint that Nagy was asked a simple question — one he also was asked Sunday afternoon at Soldier Field after the victory — and it has created more confusion than your typical Bears quarterback situation. That’s saying something.
In terms of bizarre day-after media sessions at Halas Hall, this ranks right up there with the time in 2007 when quarterback Brian Griese came to the media room a day after he led a 97-yard, 11-play touchdown drive to beat the Philadelphia Eagles 19-16. Griese had said he called some of the plays during the drive as the headset communication with offensive coordinator Ron Turner was malfunctioning. He stepped forward in a rare Monday appearance for a quarterback to clarify it was still a routine two-minute drill with normal sideline communication. Got it?
Sending PR staff to clarify the quarterback depth chart when everyone is healthy isn’t a normal part of any week.
So where does this leave the Bears, who are in much better spririts after a dominant defensive performance evened their record at 1-1? Needing to fix the offense.
Dalton led a nice drive to open the game as the Bears went 75 yards and took a 7-0 lead on his 11-yard touchdown pass to wide receiver Allen Robinson. The rest of the game was a slog. Dalton didn’t get a lot done, with the highlight after the initial drive being his 14-yard scramble — the play on which he appeared to get injured.
Fields made the kind of mistakes you see rookies experience early on. A bad interception. A fumble that was probably avoidable. A poor fourth-and-1 sneak effort and a pair of false starts.