




New York City never fails to shock visitors with its $28 cups of coffee, $34 hamburgers and dizzyingly expensive hotels. The average daily room rate reached a record $468.54 in September, according to the CoStar Group, a real estate analytics company.
But budget travelers who don’t mind spartan furnishings and shared bathrooms may find the answer to their prayers in the city’s religious guesthouses.
Most of these under-the-radar accommodations, often within walking distance of major attractions, welcome guests of any faith, or nonbelievers, at a fraction of the price of a hotel. And they come with an amenity few hotels can match: a sense of community.
“Instead of staying at a hotel, where you’re very clearly a visitor, you kind of feel like you live there — even if it’s just a week,” said Canadian filmmaker Amalie Atkins, who stayed with her family at Menno House, a Mennonite-owned guesthouse in the Gramercy Park neighborhood. Menno House charges just $125 a night for a single-occupancy room.
Faith-based organizations own more than 13% of Manhattan’s land mass, according to the Furman Center at New York University, with much of that property in or near sought-after neighborhoods. Some also own brownstones, former boardinghouses and other historic buildings designed to host visitors. That puts organizations with a hospitality mission in a prime position to open their doors to people from all over the world.
Here are five guesthouses that are worth checking into.
1. The Leo House
The largest and most hotel-like of the city’s religious guesthouses, the Leo House offers 81 rooms across eight floors in its prime location on West 23rd Street. While crucifixes decorate each room, guests need not be religious.
“There is no attempt to proselytize,” said Sister Patricia Hayes of the Congregation of Sisters of St. Agnes. “It’s more that we want to welcome you as Jesus would.” The sisters have participated in running the house since it was founded in 1889 with a grant from Pope Leo XIII. Originally opened near Battery Park to provide safe housing for German immigrants arriving in New York, the Leo House moved to Chelsea in 1926.The property, which is gradually undergoing renovations, offers four austere shared spaces and simple rooms. It has a 24-hour front desk, a business center and a hot breakfast from Monday to Saturday. Guests can also take advantage of its outdoor space, including a tidy backyard garden with ivy, herbs, hydrangeas and a statue.
Visitors may discover that they’re in saintly company when they sign the guest book. Mother Teresa stayed at the property in 1960.
Room types range from single occupancy to a suite for six. Each room has a sink and a toilet; some have full bathrooms, and others have access to shared showers. There is one ADA-compliant room.
Rooms are dynamically priced; singles start at $183, doubles, $205.
2. Menno House
This East 19th Street brownstone has its roots in the pacifist tradition of the Mennonites, who purchased it in 1958 to house conscientious objectors to the Vietnam War as they performed their alternative service. Today, the Manhattan Mennonite Fellowship uses its four floors to accommodate a mixture of long-term residents and overnight guests.
In keeping with the Mennonite value of simplicity, its spacious rooms are sparsely furnished. Each includes a queen bed, a sleeping loft with additional mattresses, clean linens and a desk. Guests share a bathroom and kitchen and have access to a common backyard.
Connection is part of the experience. Once a week, guests are invited to participate in a housewide communal meal, sometimes prepared by Greg Springer, Menno House’s manager.
Single-occupancy rooms, $125, plus $60 for each additional guest, per night; there is a two-night minimum.
3. Penington Friends House
This Quaker-run guesthouse offers guests a classic brownstone experience on a quiet, residential Gramercy street. The building, which features 14-foot ceilings and ornate crown moldings, was built by the Stuyvesant family in 1870. Quaker women founded Penington Friends House in 1897, and the property still offers long- and short-term accommodations.
The residence offers two rooms for overnight guests. The Edith Darlington Room, named after a resident from the 1970s, has two full beds, while the Phebe Room, named after one of the house’s founders, has one full bed. Each room has a private sink and toilet, with access to a common guest shower.
Dinner, which is included, is served in the communal kitchen Sunday to Thursday.
Pacifism is a core belief of Quakers, formally known as the Religious Society of Friends, a value that colors their approach to hosting. “We hope that guests experience a bit of peace with us here in Manhattan,” said Jessica Walker-Keleher, director of operations and community at Penington Friends House.
Single-occupancy rooms, $179 or $205, plus $20 for each additional adult, per night; single-night stays incur a $30 fee.
4. The Kolping House
If you’re traveling to New York with a longer-term purpose, the Kolping House offers stays of up to three months at a time. If you’re only in town for a few nights, you may still be in luck.
This 88-room Catholic residence on the Upper East Side — a 10-minute walk from Central Park, on the same street as the Guggenheim Museum — still operates largely as its founders intended when they opened its first location in 1894. The Kolping House, which moved in 1914 to this brick building designed by the architect Carl Otto, caters to interns, students and researchers but welcomes short-term guests as space permits. It typically has an 80% to 90% occupancy rate, according to Peter Carruthers, president of Kolping New York.
“It’s not a hostel situation; it’s more of a longer-term stay where you get to meet people, make friends, and those friendships are continued for many years,” Carruthers said.
The property has three floors — two for men, one for women — and a coed library. Bathrooms are shared. No alcohol is allowed in the building, and dinner is provided on weeknights.
Single-occupancy rooms, $105 a night or $325 per week; guests must pay a one-time $95 registration fee.
5. Interfaith 21
The bed-and-breakfast-style accommodations at this Chelsea guesthouse come with an opportunity to actually serve the breakfast, too. Guests can join staff members in offering a freshly cooked, vegetarian meal to those in need three times a week in Tompkins Square Park. Guests don’t have to participate, but many do.
“A lot of people will say it’s the best part of their whole trip,” said Alex Anupama, a former monk who helped start Interfaith 21 in May 2025. “The core aspect of our mission is to give people a spiritual experience,” he added.
The accommodations, in a five-story walk-up that dates to 1910, are rooted in spirituality but not necessarily a particular faith — both Buddhist and Christian art lines the walls. All 21 rooms have sinks, but bathrooms are shared. The building does not have an elevator.
Housekeeping service is available upon request. An organic continental breakfast is included and available in the building’s ground-floor kitchen.
Rooms are dynamically priced and can cost as little as $80 per night.


PREVIOUS ARTICLE