I am a second-generation Australian on my mother’s side and a first-generation Australian on my father’s. My family arrived here by way of Poland, Hungary, Germany and Romania, carrying with them experiences shaped by two of the 20th century’s most destructive ideologies: Nazism and communism.
All four of my grandparents survived or escaped the upheavals that engulfed Europe during and after World War II.
My maternal grandmother escaped Poland on a Sugihara visa through a combination of foresight, courage, luck and the kindness of strangers. Her journey took her across Siberia, through Shanghai, Kobe and Tokyo, before she eventually arrived in Australia. Most of the family she left behind were murdered.
My maternal grandfather escaped Poland by a similarly improbable route and, on arriving in Australia, enlisted in the Australian armed forces.
My paternal grandfather survived brutal forced labour in Transnistria. My paternal grandmother was born in Mannheim, Germany, and survived the war in Romania, where she and my grandfather started their family. In 1957, my father and his family escaped communist Romania. They were among the Jews who were permitted to leave through arrangements in which Romania was willing to grant freedom to its Jewish citizens only in exchange for hard currency provided by Israel.
My father eventually came to Australia for his sister’s wedding. He was studying in Italy but his family convinced him to stay and study here, where he met my mother at the University of NSW and stayed.
Members of my family survived through extraordinary acts of courage, the kindness of strangers and a series of improbable opportunities. Others were not so fortunate.
These experiences left me not with a sense of victimhood but with a profound appreciation for the fragility of liberty and the responsibility each generation bears in preserving it.
I was brought up believing I lived in the “Lucky Country”, with a deep gratitude for Australia and an understanding that the freedoms we enjoy are neither inevitable nor permanent. From an early age I understood that stability, opportunity and liberty are precious, hard won and remarkably fragile.
I was also raised in a household where the word hate was effectively banned. As children we were free to dislike things intensely, but never to hate them. At the time I thought this was excessive. My mother would patiently explain that hatred had a way of taking hold of people and leading them to places they never intended to go.
Looking back, I realise she was teaching us something far more important than good manners.
I have since tried to pass that lesson on to my own children. They often roll their eyes and tell me, “It’s just a word, Mum.” Perhaps. But I believe words matter because they shape how we think, and how we think ultimately shapes how we act.
In my later teenage years, my father encouraged me to read Elias Canetti’s Crowds and Power. At the time I read it through the eyes of a young woman growing up in what felt like the golden age of Australian multiculturalism and perhaps the most secure period in Jewish history.
Sometime after October 7, I pulled it from my bookshelf and read it again.
Canetti understood something enduring about human nature. Crowds offer belonging, purpose, certainty and moral clarity. But they can also encourage conformity, discourage dissent and reduce complex realities to simplistic narratives. The desire to belong can be one of humanity’s greatest strengths. It can also become one of its greatest vulnerabilities.
History demonstrates that societies periodically become captivated by the identification of a collective villain. One of Canetti’s enduring insights was that crowds derive cohesion from the pursuit of a common target. That dynamic should concern us whenever any minority group becomes the object of disproportionate hostility, fixation or moral obsession.
The events since October 7 have forced me to question assumptions that I once took for granted.
I am the mother of four children. Like every parent, I spend a great deal of time thinking about the world they will inherit. More than anything else, that is why I felt compelled to make this submission to the Royal Commission on Antisemitism and Social Cohesion.
The Australia I grew up in
I grew up during a period in which multicultural Australia seemed not merely to function but to flourish. It was built over decades through institutions, shared expectations and a civic culture that encouraged people from vastly different backgrounds to see themselves as part of a common national project.
My own family benefited enormously from that model. Like millions of Australians, my parents and grandparents arrived carrying different languages, traditions, histories and experiences. Australia allowed them to preserve those identities while becoming fully Australian.
Although I attended a non-Jewish school, I grew up in a proud Jewish family deeply connected to Jewish history, Jewish peoplehood and the intellectual traditions of Judaism.
I did not personally experience any significant antisemitism during my school years. It was not socially acceptable in the mainstream.
I was proud to be both Australian and Jewish, and never felt any need to conceal either identity or choose between them.
As a teenager, I joined a Jewish youth movement that gave me a sense of belonging. This sat comfortably alongside friendships with people from every conceivable background.
What united us was that we shared a common civic culture. There was a broadly accepted belief in giving people a fair go, gratitude for the opportunities this country provided and confidence that our differences could coexist within a larger Australian identity.
Australia was never perfect. Inequalities, prejudices and social tensions existed. But for many decades Australian multiculturalism demonstrated that people from vastly different backgrounds could live together peacefully, contribute meaningfully to society and maintain pride in both their heritage and their Australian identity. This is the benchmark against which I measure the changes I have witnessed in recent years.
When the abnormal
becomes normal
Since October 7, many Jewish Australians increasingly find themselves calculating the social, professional or personal cost of being visibly Jewish. Some choose to conceal aspects of their identity. Others refuse. Neither choice should be necessary in a liberal democracy.
I am sharing some personal experiences not because they are exceptional but because they have become common. They illustrate how changes in the social climate are often experienced: not through a single dramatic event but through the accumulation of small moments that alter how people move through the world.
My son, now almost 16, was 13 when he became the butt of a gas chamber joke at school. I learned about it only because another student reported it to a teacher. The school contacted me; my son had not. He wanted to protect the boy responsible, who was also his friend, from getting into trouble.
What struck me most was not malice but normalisation. The student making the jokes did not appear to grasp their significance. They had become commonplace, part of the language and humour circulating on social media platforms, particularly on TikTok.
My youngest son, now nine, was seven when he first began asking questions that no child should need to ask. Should he wear his kippah to the shops after school? Was it OK to wear a camp shirt with Hebrew writing on it when we went out to a concert? And this year: Why had large concrete barriers suddenly appeared outside his school?
I explained that they were there to protect the school.
He asked: “Because of Bondi? So cars don’t try and ram us?”
It is difficult to describe what it feels like as a parent to watch a child lose a measure of innocence in real time.
My daughter, then 13, was meeting friends in the city when a man in his 20s noticed the Star of David she was wearing and shouted, “Free Palestine”.
My daughter is not shy. She responded: “What can a 13-year-old do to free Palestine?”
The man told her he was interested in her opinion.
She asked him how many Jews there were in the world.
“About 1.5 billion,” he replied.
“There are only about 15 million,” she said. “If you’re wrong about that, maybe you’re wrong about some other things too.”
I was both immensely proud and deeply unsettled.
My daughter should not have to defend her identity, her community or a conflict thousands of kilometres away simply because she was wearing a Jewish symbol. Nor should any parent have to wonder whether the next stranger who decides to engage their child will be merely ignorant or something far worse.
My eldest daughter is about to begin university and will likely pursue a career in the arts. I hope she enters a world that values intellectual curiosity, debate and diversity of thought. Yet I would be dishonest if I said I was not concerned.
The impact extends beyond individual incidents. My brother lives in regional Australia, where friendships and social networks that had existed for years have fractured since October 7. Relationships that once transcended politics have become strained or disintegrated altogether.
These fractures rarely make headlines but they represent a real loss of social cohesion.
My own family has also had to increase security measures at home because of my husband’s public profile in the community. (Paul Rubenstein is NSW chairman of the Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council.)
Each of my children has, in different ways, developed a degree of situational awareness, resilience and identity-consciousness that most Australian children never have to acquire. While those qualities may ultimately serve them well, I wish they had not learned them quite so early.
The burden is not carried through one dramatic event.
It accumulates through a thousand small calculations.
Should I wear this?
Should I say that?
Should I post this?
Should I correct that person?
Should I conceal who I am?
These are not questions that citizens in a confident and cohesive multicultural democracy should routinely ask themselves.
The erosion of social trust, freedom and belonging is gradual. It is normalised, rationalised and dismissed until the consequences become impossible to ignore.
Understanding
contemporary
antisemitism
Most people understand antisemitism when it appears as racial hatred, conspiracy theories, Holocaust denial or neo-Nazi ideology. These manifestations still exist and should never be underestimated. However, contemporary antisemitism frequently presents itself in ways that are less obvious, more socially acceptable and therefore more difficult to identify.
The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance Working Definition of Antisemitism is an important tool because it recognises that antisemitism can be expressed not only through hostility towards Jews as individuals but also through certain forms of discourse relating to the collective Jewish experience and the state of Israel.
I have no objection to criticism of Israeli governments, policies or political leaders. Criticism of a government is not antisemitism.
The difficulty arises when criticism crosses into demonisation; when Jews are collectively held responsible for the actions of the Israeli government; when Israel is judged by standards applied to no other nation; or when Jewish self-determination alone is considered uniquely illegitimate.
This is one of the most troubling developments in civic discourse since October 7.
Increasingly, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is interpreted through broader ideological frameworks concerning colonialism, racism, privilege, oppression and power.
These frameworks often flatten a profoundly complex conflict into a simple binary of oppressor and oppressed, obscuring the competing histories, identities and national aspirations that shape it. Human beings are naturally drawn to stories that reduce complexity and offer certainty, moral clarity, clear villains and clear victims.
Jewish experience sits uneasily within these simplified frameworks. Jews are often perceived as privileged because many have achieved educational or economic success. Yet Jewish history is also one of exclusion, persecution, expulsion and vulnerability.
Like many minority groups, Jews adapted when doors to professions, land ownership and political participation were closed. Success became not merely an advantage but often a survival strategy. The result is that Jewish experience resists simplistic categories of privilege and oppression.
How did we get here?
The ideas shaping today’s conversation did not appear overnight. Many of the narratives that dominate contemporary discourse about Zionism and Israel have intellectual roots stretching back decades.
Following the Six-Day War in 1967, the Soviet Union invested heavily in anti-Zionist propaganda, portraying Zionism not as a movement of Jewish national self-determination but as a form of racism, colonialism and imperialism.
These narratives were designed to delegitimise Jewish nationalism and, over time, migrated into international institutions and parts of Western academic and activist culture, where they attached themselves to genuine concerns about racism, colonialism and inequality.
This raises a broader question: Why does Israel occupy such a uniquely symbolic place in contemporary discourse, and why does hostility directed towards it so often extend beyond the state itself to Jews around the world?
Throughout history, Jews have frequently been assigned symbolic significance far beyond their actual numbers or power. The accusations changed with the times. The underlying phenomenon remained remarkably consistent.
In different eras, Jews were accused of being capitalists and communists, outsiders and insiders, weak and powerful. The allegations often contradicted one another. Yet Jews repeatedly became vessels for broader societal anxieties and ideological preoccupations.
When Israel becomes a symbol rather than a nation-state, it ceases to be judged as other nations are judged. It becomes a repository for wider frustrations and a vehicle through which broader political and moral struggles are fought. Hostility directed towards Israel can then extend beyond the state itself to Jews around the world.
Australia is not immune to these intellectual currents. As in other Western democracies, our universities, media institutions, cultural organisations and online spaces are influenced by global ideas and narratives.
These developments are not solely organic. Democracies around the world have become targets for state and non-state actors seeking to amplify social divisions, polarisation and distrust.
While the overwhelming majority of public debate remains domestic and legitimate, it would be naive to ignore attempts by external actors to exploit existing tensions and import conflicts in ways that undermine social cohesion here.
History repeatedly demonstrates the danger of movements becoming united by a common enemy rather than a shared commitment to democratic values.
Why Israel matters
One of the things that has surprised me most in recent years is how little understanding there is of the place of Israel within Jewish identity.
For many Jews, Israel is not simply a foreign country. It is woven into our history, culture, religion and collective memory. Every synagogue faces Jerusalem, our prayers are filled with references to Zion, and for more than 2000 years Jews have maintained a spiritual, historical and emotional connection to the land. Yet Israel’s significance extends beyond religion.
For most of the past two millennia, Jews lived as minorities in other people’s societies. Sometimes they flourished. Sometimes they were tolerated. Sometimes they were expelled, persecuted or murdered. Often, the difference between those conditions changed far more quickly than people expected.
The modern state of Israel emerged only three years after the Holocaust. It became a refuge not only for survivors of Europe but also for Jews expelled from Arab countries, Soviet Jews, Ethiopian Jews and countless others who found themselves vulnerable, persecuted or without a place willing to receive them.
For my own family, Israel is not an abstraction. My father’s family found refuge there after escaping the absolutism of communist Romania.
One need not agree with every policy of an Israeli government to understand why Israel occupies such a central place in Jewish life. The deeper point is that, for many Jews, Israel represents continuity, peoplehood and the right of a historically vulnerable people to exercise self-determination in their ancestral homeland.
I sometimes find it perplexing that many Australians readily understand the profound connection Indigenous Australians have to land, history and ancestry, yet struggle to recognise that Jews also maintain an ancient connection to a particular place and story.
The histories are different, but the idea that a people can sustain a connection to land across generations should not be difficult to comprehend.
Whether one supports particular Israeli governments or not, understanding the significance of Israel to Jewish identity is essential to understanding why many Jews experience hostility directed towards Israel as something more than ordinary political criticism.
For many Jews, Israel is the place where memory, history and peoplehood converge.
Antisemitism as a
litmus test
Antisemitism is rising globally. This is not merely an Australian problem.
One of the lessons history repeatedly teaches is that antisemitism is rarely only about Jews. It often functions as a warning sign: a litmus test. A society that struggles to recognise the resurgence of antisemitism – even if in a different guise – frequently struggles to recognise other forms of intolerance as well. A society that excuses prejudice against one minority inevitably weakens the norms that protect all minorities.
It can reveal declining trust, growing tribalism, weakened civic norms and an increasing tendency to divide the world into opposing camps of good and evil, oppressor and oppressed, us and them.
I sometimes wonder what a Jewish observer from another era might recognise in parts of our contemporary discourse. Certain patterns might feel familiar.
The tendency to dismiss Jewish concerns as exaggerated or self-interested. The willingness to rationalise hostility towards Jews in service of a supposedly higher cause. The expectation that Jews explain, defend or distance themselves from the actions of other Jews. The reluctance of some bystanders to speak when doing so carries a social or professional cost.
The question before us is what kind of country Australia wishes to be. I view it as a democratic problem. Will we remain a society capable of balancing liberty with responsibility, diversity with cohesion and disagreement with mutual respect?
Or will we become another society that learns too late that the institutions, norms and values sustaining a free and pluralistic democracy are far more fragile than they appear?
Perhaps that is one reason historical memory matters so deeply to many Jews. It is not because we believe history repeats itself mechanically but because we understand how difficult it can be to distinguish between a passing social phenomenon and the early stages of something more consequential.
People living through periods of social change rarely know which moments will matter in retrospect. Most warning signs appear ordinary while they are unfolding. Unfortunately, every generation learns to recognise the antisemitism of the previous generation while remaining vulnerable to the next.
The responsibilities
we inherit
One of the most important ideas I inherited from Jewish tradition is that rights and responsibilities are inseparable. While contemporary discourse rightly emphasises rights, Jewish thought places equal emphasis on obligations. A mitzvah is not simply a good deed; it is a duty put into action. A free society depends on both rights and responsibilities: rights protect liberty; responsibilities preserve it.
Rabbi Jonathan Sacks argued that freedom endures not through laws alone but through citizens accepting obligations to one another and the common good. That insight is especially relevant to multicultural Australia.
Multiculturalism is not merely a contract of rights but a social compact of mutual responsibility. Diversity flourishes only where civic responsibility sustains social cohesion. The question is not only what rights we seek to protect but what responsibilities we are prepared to accept.
There is a teaching in Pirkei Avot (Ethics of the Fathers) that has stayed with me: “It is not your duty to finish the work, but neither are you free to desist from it.”
I do not expect any inquiry, government or generation to eliminate prejudice entirely. The work of sustaining a free and cohesive society is never complete, but that does not absolve us of responsibility. Perhaps that is why, since October 7, I have often reflected on the words inscribed on a local RSL building that I had passed countless times without truly seeing: “The price of liberty is eternal vigilance.” They remind us that democracy, freedom and social cohesion are neither inevitable nor self-sustaining.
The purpose of studying history should not be to cultivate pride at all costs nor shame at all costs. A mature society should acknowledge both its failures and its achievements.
The challenge for the next generation is not only to identify what must be changed but to recognise what must be preserved.
Liberty endures only when citizens recognise threats to it, speak out against them and accept responsibility for its defence. Every generation inherits that responsibility anew.
This is an edited extract of a submission to the Royal Commission on Antisemitism and Social Cohesion by Amber Rubenstein, a mother of four and a design consultant who lives in Sydney.