
An internal city audit found that Austin does not thoroughly review city credit card transactions, consider whether purchases are an efficient use of public funds or provide adequate training for credit card management.
The draft audit report also found that Austin issues more city credit cards and uses them more frequently than peer cities.
“The City is not doing all it can to protect public funds, and the City’s current approach has real consequences,” auditors wrote in the draft report.
City staff will present the report to the City Council’s Audit and Finance Committee on Wednesday.
The audit examined credit card transactions from fiscal year 2025, excluding Austin Energy cards. Those charges totaled nearly $45 million across 1,571 individual credit cards.
The broader audit follows several other internal probes released since 2020 that revealed specific instances of apparent city credit card abuse.
In one case, auditors found that a former Austin Energy employee charged nearly $1 million to his credit card to pay fictitious vendors over a six-year period.
Another found that a former Austin Water program manager charged tens of thousands of dollars to his city credit card to pay contractors for unauthorized work.
An American-Statesman investigation last year also revealed questionable credit card spending by Austin’s top executives that prompted some leaders to pay back thousands of dollars.
More credit cardsAuditors found that Austin has more credit cards than other cities in Texas, surpassing Dallas, El Paso, Fort Worth, Houston and San Antonio.
To normalize differences among the cities, auditors compared the number of employees with the number of cards and found that Austin still had more than three times as many cards per employee as Dallas and almost four times as many as San Antonio.
Auditors also divided the amount spent by the number of cards for the cities that reported their figures and found that Austin spent $5,000 more per card than the next highest city.
Unclear transactionsAuditors found that the city’s credit card transaction documentation is sometimes unclear.
The auditors analyzed 120 transactions across four Austin departments.
They found that 25 transactions, or 21%, did not have a clear description of what was bought, 42 transactions, or 35%, lacked a clear description of the business need for the purchase and 38 transactions, or 32%, had descriptions that only partially matched or did not match the receipt.
Most accountants told the auditors that their primary role was to check that transactions have supporting documentation and an assigned purchase category rather than ensuring the purchases were clear and necessary.
Austin’s review process includes checks by cardholders, supervisors and department accountants, but auditors said some transactions do not receive a first-level review.
Auditors also found that 4,541 transactions were auto-approved, meaning the transaction did not have a first-level review and went straight from the cardholder to the accountant.
“Based on our observation, some Austin transactions are not documented in a way that would reassure the public that all City credit card spending is needed or appropriate,” the report said.
Auditors also found that the city does not analyze overall credit card spending to identify whether purchases are efficient.
Two of the three largest spending categories were generic: $4.2 million was coded to “small tools/minor equipment” and $2.8 million to “services-other.”
The city also spent $2.5 million on educational travel.
Poor staff trainingAustin does not regularly review the need for all issued credit cards, revoke cards from staff who do not regularly use them or ensure that users are trained on how credit cards should be used, the auditors found.
“Relaxed policies allow staff to keep cards they have been issued even though they may not need them,” they wrote in the report.
Auditors found that at least 27% of Austin’s credit cards were used less than once a month.
They noted that continuing to grant access to underused cards “exposes the City to more chances for inappropriate use and unnecessary financial loss.”
The audit also found that Austin lacked adequate training for credit card use.
While the other Texas cities auditors reviewed required initial and periodic refresher training, Austin only requires initial training.
Auditors noted that Austin’s training does not include substantive information on card use policies and city staff told the auditors that gaps in training led to issues with credit card use such as poorly documented transactions or late approvals.
In a survey, 37% of card users said they did not remember the training or did not find it helpful.
RecommendationsAuditors recommended that the city revoke underutilized credit cards at least on an annual basis, revise city training on credit cards and implement recurring refresher training, strengthen monitoring and implement a strategy to identify cost-saving opportunities in credit card purchases.
Austin Financial Services staff said they agreed with the recommendations in the report.
They said they would create a process for reviewing card use and recommend that departments revoke cards with little or no activity, while allowing departments to request exceptions. Staff also said they would update training, require annual refreshers, assess departments’ card use annually and provide spending reports to identify efficiency opportunities.
All of the changes would begin in October 2027.