
‘If the Labour Party could select a King,” asserted the dock workers leader and Labour MP Ben Tillett in 1918, “he would be a feminist, a Temperance crank, a Nonconformist charlatan ... an anti-sport, anti-jollity advocate, a teetotaller, as well as a general wet blanket … Horse-racing would vanish and as for music halls, they would be anathema.”
Since its earliest days there has always been a division inside Labour between a sort of orderly leftism of abstract principle and moral restraint (“total abstinence and a good filing system”, as the socialist thinker Tony Crosland characterised it) and a more class-based labourism of people like Tillett: ideologically messier, at once more libertarian and more socially conservative, with a strong streak of nationalism. I suppose nowadays this labourism would be characterised as Blue Labour.
From this tradition comes Morgan McSweeney, the prime minister’s chief of staff, driven by his loathing of the hard left he encountered and defeated in Lambeth council, and determined to turn around the national party he inherited from them. “No gender, no borders, no Queen” is the withering description he made of even the soft-left alternative to his approach.
I am very appreciative of McSweeney. There is a lot I agree with him about and I am grateful that he took on Jeremy Corbyn and his supporters. As you might imagine, there is much in his social conservatism and nationalism with which I am sympathetic. I also think he is well motivated, that he really cares about the good of the country.
But I believe that what he is doing cannot work, that his partnership with Keir Starmer is doomed and that Labour cannot be again the party that he wants it to be.
My colleagues Patrick Maguire and Gabriel Pogrund provide an excellent account of McSweeney’s thinking and activities in their book Get In. And from this, three things seem obvious.
First, McSweeney kept what he was doing secret, disguising his objectives, his methods and his donors. Recently there has been a fuss about his failure to declare the donations given to Labour Together, his organising group. And it is, indeed, an important and revealing episode. He didn’t want to make public his donor (Sir Trevor Chinn, who is Jewish) or the scale of the funding (which would have made clear he was conducting a lot of polling).
What you say and what people hear aren’t always the same thing
The reason for keeping this secret was that the party he was trying to win over wasn’t a party in tune with him, and he knew that. He couldn’t be honest with them. He thought if he was open, he’d be stopped.
Second, Starmer’s leadership started with McSweeney rather than with Starmer. McSweeney was casting around for someone who could lead the party. He chose Starmer because he travelled light ideologically, was clearly professional and intelligent and had a good CV.
But it wasn’t particularly a meeting of minds.
A somewhat buttoned-up human rights lawyer from Kentish Town with a left-liberal history is an absurd person to pick to lead a Blue Labour project. But it is not at all an absurd person to pick in order to win the Labour leadership. Because those are two different things. The very choice of Starmer was an acknowledgment by McSweeney that the party he was in couldn’t be the party he wanted it to be.
The third thing an account of the last election makes clear is that the Blue Labour project of winning red wall voters didn’t work. The right split and Labour won a landslide.
But it won a pitiful vote share and in many working-class seats it actually lost votes.
Labour is now the party of the professional middle class and not the party of the socially conservative working class. It cannot win those voters back and trying to do so is plunging it into confusion — as the absurd episode over indefinite leave to remain this week illustrates.
Years ago, I provided William Hague with a line for a speech on the economy which employed the US political strategist James Carville’s famous observation about elections: “It’s the economy, stupid.” When I later asked William how it had gone he said: “Not very well. The audience thought I was calling them stupid, and looked quite cross.”
I learnt a valuable lesson, that what you say and what people hear aren’t always the same thing. If you sat down with a transcription service and a piece of graph paper, I am sure you could show that Starmer calling Reform’s policy racist and then Shabana Mahmood moving the government’s policy in the same direction was completely consistent.
Because he wasn’t, you know, calling Reform voters racist, and she wasn’t, erm, announcing almost exactly the same policy. But people don’t sit down with transcription services and graph paper. And to most people who heard any of it, it just seems like Labour is totally confused about what it is saying. Which it is.
More than that, it will appear as if, for all that he is trying to be McSweeney’s Blue Labour prime minister, Starmer isn’t that person.
For all that he talked in his conference speech of not patronising working people over racism, he was far more comfortable with the liberal riff that followed. If Labour are chasing Reform voters, which they say they are, the prime minister’s comments were a disaster.
The thing is, there are plenty of professional middle-class people who actually agree with Starmer.
There’s a coalition big enough to win elections. It just isn’t the one McSweeney is trying to build. Labour is the party of working people, Starmer said in his speech, as his audience here in Liverpool waved flags. But I don’t think it is or can be.
The Labour Party is the party of people who cheered when the party promised a second referendum on Brexit. And it is led by the man who offered that second referendum. He is not the obvious or right person to lead his party to McSweeney’s position.
Labour can no longer be a working class party, under any leader
But I think that position is hopelessly nostalgic. The Labour Party was founded as two things — a socialist party and a working-class party. McSweeney realises it cannot and must not any longer be the first of those things but hasn’t worked out that it can’t be the second, either.
Certainly not under this leader, but probably not under any leader.
In the meantime, the prime minister and his chief of staff are a mismatched pair. We have made a speciality in this country of tying together prime ministers with political gurus pursuing entirely different strategies. Dominic Cummings with Boris Johnson, Nick Timothy with Theresa May, Steve Hilton with David Cameron and now McSweeney with Starmer.
I’m politically closer to McSweeney than to Starmer but this can’t end with both of them still in power. It may well end with neither of them still in power.