In recent weeks, a Bill Gates paper has been making the rounds of boardrooms. In it he introduces a new term – “human reserved”.
The idea is straightforward. As artificial intelligence and robotics become capable of doing more, there will be some activities we consciously choose to keep human. Not because machines are incapable of doing them, but because we decide there is value in humans continuing to do them.
There is a commercial version of this argument worth considering. As we race to identify what can be automated, we should be equally clear about what shouldn’t be. And that shouldn’t be a debate about protecting jobs. It should be a debate about protecting the human capabilities that create competitive advantage. AI will make companies vastly more efficient. That is progress and companies should pursue it aggressively. But efficiency and competitive advantage are not the same thing. Once competitors have access to broadly similar technology, much of the productivity dividend becomes table stakes. Advantage still has to come from somewhere. One place it has always come from is ideas.
We tend to romanticise ideas as moments of individual genius, but most significant ideas don’t arrive fully formed. They are built on what came before, combined with something from somewhere else, challenged and improved by other people.
The University of Sydney’s Charles Perkins Centre was established to tackle complex health problems, but its premise is that these involve biology, behaviour, economics, food systems, the built environment and many other factors. So, the centre deliberately brings together people from medicine and science with engineers, architects, philosophers, agricultural researchers and writers. That isn’t collaboration for collaboration’s sake. It is a recognition that the quality of an answer is affected by the diversity of perspectives applied to the problem.
AI removes much of the need to find another person with a different perspective. If I need to understand something outside my expertise, I can ask a machine. If I want a counterargument, I can ask it to construct one. It will increasingly be able to black-hat our ideas, identify weaknesses, model scenarios and draw on a breadth of knowledge no individual human could match.
The rational response will be to remove meetings and interactions from organisations. The danger is that in removing organisational friction we also remove some of the collisions that create new thinking.
There is a strong commercial reason to care. An analysis of 15 years of Cannes Lions results compared companies that performed at the highest level creatively with their financial performance. Among the top creative performers, 67 per cent recorded above-average organic revenue growth, 70 per cent delivered above-average shareholder returns and 74 per cent achieved above-average enterprise value relative to earnings.
The point isn’t that winning creative awards causes companies to outperform. It is that the ability to produce original thinking appears disproportionately often in high-performing organisations.
When anyone can generate 100 plausible answers to a problem, generating the 101st isn’t particularly valuable. Choosing the right one is. So is knowing which problem was worth solving in the first place. Judgment, taste, imagination, curiosity and conviction become more important as the cost of execution falls.
Increasingly, as a result of advancements, we’re redesigning organisations across three dimensions.
Workflow processes have accumulated over decades because of the limitations of the technology. AI gives us the opportunity to redesign those processes rather than simply make each step faster. Workforce is the people and capabilities we need when machines can perform an increasing proportion of the work. The answer cannot simply be today’s organisation with fewer people. The skills that become more valuable will change, as will the combinations of people we put around problems.
And then there is the workbench: the expanding collection of models, agents, data, platforms and tools that people use to do their jobs. Increasingly, the capability of an organisation will be determined not simply by the people it employs, but by the intelligence those people can access.
The goal of redesigning workflow should not be the fewest possible human interactions. It should be the fewest unnecessary ones, while deliberately creating the interactions that produce better outcomes.
The goal of redesigning the workforce should not simply be fewer people. It should be a different mix of people, with more of their time directed towards judgment, imagination, relationships and solving problems across traditional boundaries.
And the goal of the new workbench should not be to replace human intelligence. It should be to give humans vastly more intelligence to work with.
Accenture Song’s report, Applied Creativity and How to Lead It, shows the opportunity. Surveying 1725 executives across 14 countries, it found 81 per cent believed their organisations could generate creative ideas, yet only 16 per cent very frequently turned those ideas into growth initiatives. The gap is telling. The problem isn’t a shortage of ideas, it’s what happens to them next.
Advantage won’t come simply from embedding AI. It will come from what we do with ideas. That is where human reserved is not just an interesting concept from Bill Gates. It should be seen as an intentional design principle to create competitive advantage.
Matt Michael is chief executive of Droga5 Australia & New Zealand, and managing director of Accenture Song.