WHY USMAN KHAWAJA STILL WON’T ANSWER THE OBVIOUS QUESTIONS
Gemma Tognini

Cricket is my favourite game on the planet: to sleep to. I’m not a great fan. I was, once. Growing up in Perth, it was Lillee and Marsh. Then the reign of the great Allan Border. The likes of Merv Hughes. Taylor, Waugh, Boon. Dean Jones.

Then Langer, Hayden, Gilly and Ponting. Ooh-ahh, Glenn McGrath. These were golden years. Before cricket got boring, got political and lost itself in anything and everything but winning games. When the Australian team captain is better known for his pet political causes than anything else.

So yes, these days I don’t mind a bit of cricket when I need something to put me to sleep. No sleeping this week, though, thanks to retired batsman Usman Khawaja.

Khawaja has written a book. It’s about his life and his career, and over the past week or so, as is common practice, advance excerpts were released to media in a prepublication PR blitz.

In case you’ve been locked in a butcher’s meat safe or similar this week, let me quickly recap where this has all landed. Among the advanced sections of Khawaja’s book was a chapter on the historic episode in Australian cricket known as Sandpapergate. Remember the now notorious 2018 Test series in South Africa where the youngest bloke on the team, Cameron Bancroft, was caught on camera using sandpaper to condition the match ball? I do, clearly. It was THE news in Australia for weeks on end. Only three players were sanctioned: Bancroft, David Warner and captain Steve Smith.

Now, nearly a decade later Khawaja hasn’t just reopened the wound; he has taken the knife, sliced through the scar tissue and cut the thing up like there’s no tomorrow.

Everyone knew. The whole team, the touring group, everyone. This is Khawaja’s claim in the 22 pages that revive the ghosts of scandals past.

They say there’s no such thing as bad publicity. May I refer you then, to Khawaja’s midweek interview on the ABC’s 7.30? So catastrophically bad was the interview that the next day he pulled out of all planned TV and radio interviews to promote the book.

Khawaja fell plumb LBW before a very straight set of bowling from the ABC’s Sarah Ferguson. She didn’t even bowl him a flipper. Her questions were neither unexpected nor difficult, they were exactly the kind of question you would ask after the kind of accusations Khawaja made, chief among them being this: Did Pat Cummins, now Australian captain, have prior knowledge of the fact sandpaper was being used to change the surface of the ball?

Khawaja refused to answer. What then followed was 12 odd minutes of intermittent gibberish, a meandering narrative that sashayed between the following topics: unfair media treatment, protesting that his former teammates (the ones he has deftly dropped into the pooper) really are his friends, and how he’s only human too. How there needs to be collective responsibility taken for Sandpapergate and how deeply he “felt for those three guys” who took the brunt of it. Not deeply enough, though, to have spoken out at the time that it mattered most.

The interview was a masterclass in what not to do, unless your goal is to turn up unprepared for obvious questions, projecting weapons-grade hubris, and at times making no sense whatsoever. If that’s the aim, then do exact­ly what he did.

Ferguson continued to press him on the question of precisely who knew what. She was fair and, in my view, showed a great restraint. I’d have gone full metal jacket.

Khawaja? He was just writing from a safe space, man.

“I’m not here to inflame the situation any more I’m just here to speak my truth … I wrote about it (Sandpapergate) in my book because it was a safe space.”

Well, bugger me! If anything sums up this generation of Australian cricketers, here it is. My truth. Safe space. Can you imagine the great AB, after enduring 15 losses on the trot on taking over as captain, saying to journalists: Look, guys, I’m not answering your questions. I’m just here to speak my truth in a safe space.

There is no such thing as “my truth” for any of us. It’s a nonsense phrase made up to coddle people who want to avoid hard conversations, hard things and the need for accountability.

Anthony Albanese’s truth is that he neither fell off that stage, nor sexually objectified the Japanese Prime Minister. His truth, not the truth.

Khawaja hid behind “his truth” repeatedly this week. His truth is “complete and utter nonsense”, according to Cummins. He called Khawaja’s allegations of an all-in cover-up “100 per cent wrong” and revealed he’d had advice during the week that some of his former teammate’s claims might be defamatory, though denied he would act on that advice. Khawaja’s “safe space” doesn’t look that safe any more but I guess that’s what happens when you dump a truckload over people you insist are your friends.

Australians have a complicated relationship with our sporting heroes. We like to venerate them, but the bitterness is real when we feel they have betrayed our trust or acted in a way that is un-Australian or unsportsmanlike.

The reasons are many and sometimes fickle, yet it’s a reminder that our heroes are also human, with their own frailties and character flaws and the like. Kind of like when you realise your parents are not superhuman, just normal people muddling through life, trying to raise their kids.

My sporting heroes are Phar Lap and Dawn Fraser, so I feel I’ve gotten off lightly in that regard.

All of this aside, in general I reckon Aussies are pretty quick to forgive when repentance is swift and real.

This somehow feels different. Khawaja is a talented athlete who played for his country at the highest level, in one of the most venerated positions in our cultural lexicon. He wore the baggy green. Like Bradman. Like Warne.

But he seems to bristle, to rub people up the wrong way, and I get why. Examples such as this, for one. Last year Khawaja was criticised ahead of his final Test series. It centred on his choice to prepare for a golf tournament the day before the Ashes opening Test. Cricket Australia defended him, but Khawaja claimed in a press conference in January this year that the media reports that criticised him were racially motivated and told journalists: “It was about something very personal; it was about my preparation … things like, ‘He’s not committed to the team, he was only worried about himself, he played this golf comp the day before, he’s selfish, he doesn’t train hard enough, he didn’t train the day before the game, he’s lazy.’ These are the same … racial stereotypes I’ve grown up with my whole life.”

How is saying “Mate, you shouldn’t have played golf” racial stereotyping? I just don’t see how and, for what it’s worth, neither did bowling great Jason Gillespie who responded like this: “Being questioned … and being held to account over your choices, that’s not bullying, it’s not abuse, that’s all part and parcel of being a professional. You can’t really throw a temper tantrum when asked to take accountability for a job you’re actually paid to do.”

Likewise, in the book, Khawaja claims the colour of his skin was the reason he wasn’t made captain in the wake of the scandal.

“They (Cricket Australia) weren’t ready for a brown Australian cricket captain, even as an interim.”

That’s a mighty big call to make and, interestingly, one he was at pains to walk back during his disastrous ABC interview. Tim Paine was the right choice, he said. So, old mate, which was it – overt, inexcusable racism or the right choice? I’ve no doubt that Khawaja experienced racism in his life but that’s another discourse.

For me, the most grating parts of this episode are twofold. I’ve had to read more about cricket in the past week than I ever have and I do not consider that time well spent.

Second: it’s wild, don’t you think, Khawaja framing these revelations as if he’s some kind of Erin Brockovich revealing the truth at great cost. What cost? He’s retired. No spot on the team to risk. Eight years ago, the cost of speaking up would have been significant. That would have taken some stones, some courage. I could respect that. Who wouldn’t?

Waiting nearly a decade, putting these claims into a book you’re releasing just before Christmas and the start of the cricket season? Khawaja says that was not his motivation. I don’t buy that, and I won’t be buying the book. You can decide for yourself.