Print      
Toshiba fighting for its survival
Company warns business may be too crippled to fix
Toshiba Corp. President Satoshi Tsunakawa on Tuesday apologized to shareholders for the company’s difficulties. (Shizuo Kambayashi/Associated Press)
By Jonathan Soble and Paul Mozur
New York Times

NEW YORK — Toshiba, a pillar of the modern Japanese economy whose roots stretch back to the country’s industrial stirrings in the 19th century, warned on Tuesday that a disastrous foray into nuclear power may have crippled its business beyond repair.

In a stock-market filing in Japan, Toshiba said losses associated with Westinghouse Electric, its troubled US nuclear power subsidiary, had created “substantial uncertainty’’ over its ability to continue as a going concern. The declaration lifts the stakes as Toshiba seeks outside investors for its coveted microchip business, a portion of which it is selling off to raise cash and stave off disaster.

Toshiba’s uncertain fate represents another blow for a country that has seen its dominance in a range of technologies eclipsed by rivals in South Korea and China.

Few companies have embodied Japan’s industrial might like Toshiba, whose products run the gamut from hair dryers to giant gas-fired electricity turbines, as well as nuclear reactors. But it has faced a spate of recent stumbles in core businesses as well as a scandal over falsified profits that came to light in 2015.

Toshiba said it hoped the planned sale of shares in its chip division, its crown jewel, would alleviate the uncertainty over its future. While Toshiba has not said exactly how much of the business it will sell, even a minority stake is expected to be worth several billion dollars.

Any stability, though, would come at a price. Toshiba would be parting with portions of its most profitable asset and giving a competitor — very likely a foreign one — a foothold in the market for flash memory drives, where Japan has managed to retain some of its long-held edge.

“We will do what we can to avoid being delisted from the stock exchange,’’ Satoshi Tsunakawa, Toshiba’s chief executive, said at a news conference after apologizing to shareholders for Toshiba’s latest worrying turn. The company reported financial details for the quarter that ended in December after multiple delays and disputes with its auditors.

The financial problems are mounting.

The auditors have refused to certify Toshiba’s accounts — a highly unusual signal of doubt about the company’s ability to recover its financial health. Toshiba still has the support of its banks, which would be saddled with huge losses if they were to push the company into bankruptcy by calling in loans. But the auditors are, in effect, saying that Toshiba may need to undertake a more radical overhaul to ensure its survival.

Toshiba has already admitted defeat in nuclear power.

Westinghouse filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in the United States last month, and Toshiba took a loss of more than $6 billion as it wrote down the value of the subsidiary, which it acquired in 2006 to further ambitions to become a world-leading nuclear-energy provider. Spiraling costs at US reactor projects, the upheaval caused by the 2011 Fukushima meltdown in Japan, and competition from shale oil and gas output have hurt the company.

The chip sale will, in some ways, be more painful.

Pioneered by Toshiba nearly 40 years ago, so-called NAND flash memory has become one of the crucial building blocks of modern electronics, essential to storing data in smartphones and other gadgets. And Toshiba has kept the business profitable while competitors outside Japan have elbowed into the market and competed for its customers.

The identities of the bidders for shares of the chip business have not been made public. But people with knowledge of the process say as many as a dozen companies from the United States, South Korea, and Taiwan have approached Toshiba with proposals.

Foxconn of Taiwan, the assembler of Apple iPhones and other electronics, which has big manufacturing operations in mainland China, is among the bidders, according to a person familiar with the matter who asked not to be identified because he was not authorized to discuss it.

Other potential investors include US microchip makers Western Digital and Broadcom and SK Hynix of South Korea.

For Foxconn, an investment in Toshiba would be the second recent foray into the often politically fraught world of corporate Japan. Last year Foxconn acquired control of Sharp, the maker of flat-screen television displays, for $3.5 billion. In doing so, it overcame a rival bid from an investment fund backed by the Japanese government.

Toshiba’s microchip business is seen as a more valuable asset than a business in TV screens. Japan — despite having pioneered LCD, or liquid crystal displays — has lost most of its market share in TV screens to South Korea and China.

Samsung of South Korea has overtaken Toshiba in NAND, but Toshiba remains the world’s second-biggest producer, with a global share of just under 20 percent, according to market research groups. Analysts say Toshiba’s technology, commonly used in smartphones and USB drives, remains at the cutting edge.

One analyst, Mark Newman, of Sanford C. Bernstein, argued in a report that Toshiba’s memory business remained valuable enough that selling it amounted to “selling the crown jewels to pay next month’s rent.’’