Print      
Website concerns Maine Democrats
Want conservative site investigated
By Brian MacQuarrie
Globe Staff

The Maine Examiner, an Internet news site with anonymous reporters and undisclosed owners, describes itself as “a small group of Mainers who simply publish Maine news, trends, and interesting pieces about you, the people of Maine.’’

The Maine Democratic Party has other suspicions. The Democrats this week asked the state ethics commission to investigate whether the conservative website has violated campaign finance laws and is secretly working in conjunction with the state Republican Party.

“We are deeply concerned with the dangerous precedent this type of anonymous communication could set in Maine,’’ the party said in a complaint filed Tuesday with the ethics panel, an independent agency that can levy fines and refer cases to the state attorney general.

The Democratic Party complained to the panel following a barrage of controversial attacks by the Examiner against Lewiston mayoral candidate Ben Chin, a Democrat, leading up to the Dec. 12 election.

“The stories made inflammatory claims about Mr. Chin and attempted to disparage his character,’’ the complaint said.

Chin lost that election by 145 votes to a candidate he had outpolled, 42 percent to 29 percent, in a five-person preliminary race in November. The 32-year-old Bates College graduate blamed his razor-thin defeat partly on the Examiner’s stories, some of which were based on leaked emails and shared with a vastly broader audience on the state GOP Facebook page.

The state GOP’s executive director, Jason Savage, also shared Examiner stories on his personal Facebook page.

Savage and state GOP spokesman Garrett Murch could not be reached for comment. The Maine Examiner did not reply to an email request for comment.

However, the Examiner strongly defended its reporting in a Jan. 17 post. Under a byline of “Administrator,’’ the Examiner wrote that “not a single article published by Maine Examiner has proven ‘fake’ or false.’’

The ethics commission is scheduled to meet Feb. 22 and might discuss the complaint at that time, said Paul Lavin, the panel’s assistant director. The panel of five “citizen-members’’ is appointed by the governor and consists of two Democrats, two Republicans, and one independent, he said.

The state Democratic Party, in the complaint, asked the Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics and Election Practices to investigate whether the Examiner worked closely with the state GOP.

“We believe that the GOP is using them as a foil, spreading false information for election purposes,’’ state Democratic chairman Phil Bartlett said of the Examiner in an interview. “We are asking for an investigation to examine what the relationship is, who’s responsible.’’

The complaint noted that the state Republican Party listed seven “operating expenses’’ for Facebook advertising between Dec. 6 and 13, a period that closely follows the Examiner’s seven stories on Chin.

The Maine GOP recorded no other Facebook ad expenses for the quarter stretching from October through December, the Democrats said.

“We request that the commission investigate all expenditures the Maine Examiner and any other organizations made in support of the production and dissemination of the stories about Mr. Chin,’’ the complaint said.

The Democrats also argued that the Examiner appeared to have violated a state law that prohibits an “independent expenditure’’ for any communication “that expressly advocates the election or defeat of a clearly identified candidate.’’

The Examiner does not enjoy a press exemption from this requirement, the complaint said, because the company does not identify who owns and controls its site.

“The Maine Examiner has not only failed to make this information public, but it has taken steps to conceal the identity of any and all individuals associated with the organization,’’ the complaint read.

Such anonymity becomes dangerous, the Democrats said, when readers do not know who is behind the attacks.

The Examiner made its first foray into the Lewiston race on Dec. 3, accusing Chin of criticizing racial attitudes in a city where many residents resisted an influx of thousands of Somali immigrants.

“Leaked Email: Ben Chin Says Lewiston Voters ‘Bunch of Racists,’ ’’ the Examiner’s headline read that day. The email, however, clearly indicates that Chin was not speaking generally about Lewiston residents.

The Examiner also posted that Chin retained a convicted pedophile as a campaign volunteer, although Chin said the man did not participate in election activities and was asked not to appear at campaign events.

Examiner stories routinely do not contact Chin or the other Democrats they have targeted. In its Jan. 17 post, the site dismissed the argument that anonymity is a concern.

“What those attacking us would like to do is ignore the facts in our stories and attack us personally to try to silence us,’’ the post read. “We will not be silenced. We will continue publishing fact-based news and content.’’

The Democrats, who take issue with that description, urged the ethics panel to promote transparency.

“In order to make judgments about the veracity and value of stories covering Maine candidates, Mainers must understand who is behind the communication,’’ the complaint said. “In the absence of required disclosures, Mainers do not know whether organizations are run and funded by their neighbors, a political organization or campaign, or a foreign government.’’

Brian MacQuarrie can be reached at brian.macquarrie@globe.com.