
No championship parade, no banner to unfurl, and no documentaries to produce for the Patriots this year.
But it certainly has not been a quiet start to the offseason in Foxborough. There’s a lot still to unpack from the Patriots’ 41-33 loss to the Eagles in Super Bowl LII, the Malcolm Butler situation, Josh McDaniels’s stunning about-face, and the power dynamics between the Krafts, Bill Belichick, and Tom Brady:
■ One thing that became clear last week: Boy, did the Patriots coaches have a lot on their minds during their two weeks of Super Bowl preparation.
McDaniels was wavering between the Colts job and staying in New England, and still was talking to coaches behind the scenes about creating a staff in Indianapolis. Matt Patricia was putting a staff together and getting his affairs in order to leave for Detroit.
Special teams coordinator Joe Judge had an expiring contract and didn’t know if he was staying. Same with assistant quarterbacks coach Jerry Schuplinski. Offensive line coach Dante Scarnecchia and running backs coach Ivan Fears were considering retirement if a new coaching staff was coming in.
Were these distractions significant enough to affect the team’s preparation? The Patriots are better than most at compartmentalizing, but coaches are only human. At minimum, it couldn’t have been a positive to have all the uncertainty swirling around their futures, which affects their careers and their families. At maximum, their heads weren’t fully in the game.
“I can’t imagine anybody so strong mentally and so able to compartmentalize that that wasn’t affecting what was occupying your mind and your ability to focus,’’ a former NFL executive said.
■ Which brings another important question to light: Why did the Patriots wait so long to convince McDaniels to stay? They have known for a month that he interviewed for three head coaching jobs. And reports about McDaniels heading to the Colts have been out there for weeks. But only on Tuesday morning, as McDaniels was about to clean out his office and head to Indy, did the Patriots step up with an offer to keep him.
One theory we heard from two separate league sources that makes a lot of sense: The Super Bowl proved to the Krafts that they needed protection from or leverage against Belichick.
We know that the Krafts were as surprised as anyone at the Butler benching. They were also surprised that Belichick only got a paltry second-round pick from the 49ers for Jimmy Garoppolo.
Keeping McDaniels really may have been less about having a succession plan, and more about giving the Krafts more control over the situation. If the tension between the Krafts, Belichick, and Brady persists, or if Belichick decides to leave the organization in the next year or two, the Krafts now have a backup plan in McDaniels.
The timing of the McDaniels move calls into question how involved Belichick was in bringing him back. Obviously, keeping McDaniels in the fold makes Belichick’s life a lot easier. Now he only has to replace his defensive coordinator, instead of both coordinators, a quarterbacks coach, a special teams coordinator, and multiple assistants. It could perhaps lengthen Belichick’s coaching career, as he still has most of his trusted personnel.
But again, Belichick has known about this possibility for a month. If he wanted the continuity, he could have blocked McDaniels from interviewing until the season was over (like Belichick did with Nick Caserio and Monti Ossenfort), or sweetened his deal weeks or months ago. Instead, he let the uncertainty linger over McDaniels, and almost lost him to Indianapolis.
It certainly appears that Belichick was OK with letting McDaniels move on, and that McDaniels is back mostly because the Krafts wanted him.
■ And yes, despite Belichick and Robert Kraft dining together at Davio’s on Monday night, tension definitely still exists in Patriot Place. The meeting at Davio’s was all for show, to present a united front to the media and public. There is no reason to hold a meeting in such a public setting, right in the middle of the main dining room, other than wanting to be seen.
■ McDaniels may have hurt his image and upset a lot of people with his decision, but he definitely chose a sure thing in New England over an uncertain situation in Indianapolis and it’s hard to blame him. Colts general manager Chris Ballard’s admission that Andrew Luck still hasn’t thrown a football means that the Colts will have no clarity on Luck’s long-term prognosis by the time the draft rolls around in April. That doesn’t sound like the job to stake your reputation to, and when the Krafts stepped in and sweetened McDaniels’s contract last week, the decision became easy.
But McDaniels’s indecisiveness is nothing new. In 2014, he went back and forth several times with the Browns between badly wanting the head coaching job to not being sure if he truly wanted it, before finally dropping out of consideration. Same with his pursuit of the 49ers job last year. McDaniels and his family were scarred by their stint in Denver, and McDaniels still battles internally over whether he wants to go through it all again. A report last week stated that the Bears also had concerns about McDaniels’s willingness to leave Foxborough.
The Colts were definitely aware of McDaniels’s indecisive history, yet felt the risk was worth the reward.
■ Not much clarity has come to the Butler benching, other than several of his teammates didn’t agree with it. Butler certainly wasn’t a saint this season, letting his public contract frustration affect his preparation and his attitude. And in hindsight, the fact that he missed the team flight should have tipped us off that something was awry (if Butler were truly sick, he would still likely fly with the team so he could be with the medical staff). Butler was probably leaving New England in free agency no matter what.
But those “likes’’ and comments from teammates, including Brady, on Butler’s Instagram post absolutely were a sign of support for Butler. Most coaches would have to work to win over the locker room, but Belichick has his reasons for benching Butler, and likely doesn’t care if his players agreed with the decision or not. The players will fall in line for him next year regardless.
■ The other major story that has somewhat been buried is the future of Rob Gronkowski, and whether he is really going to retire after eight NFL seasons.
If you tell me that Gronk might walk away because his body has taken a beating, he has made about $46 million on the field and probably just as much off the field, and still has a lucrative future ahead as a brand and personality, I’m definitely listening. He has put his body (and head) through a lot in eight seasons, and it would be hard to blame him if he walked away while still intact.
But stop with the nonsense that Gronk is going to retire from football in order to be an action movie star. That’s make-believe, not a realistic option. Acting is hard, and Gronk is not good at it. You don’t just snap your fingers and become a bankable movie star. Gronk is not overtaking The Rock or Chris Evans any time soon.
It sounds like Gronk is simply angling for a new contract — or, more specifically, a similar incentive package to the one the Patriots gave him last year.
Gronk was supposed to make $5 million last year, and the Patriots gave him $5.5 million in incentives, which he achieved. Now he is set to make between $8 million and $9 million this year, based on how many games he plays. It’s a nice living, but the going rate for top wide receivers is $15 million per year, and Gronk has every right to ask to be paid similarly.
Another $5 million incentive package could keep the big fella happy. And it wouldn’t even count against the Patriots’ salary cap in 2018 if they can find a way to make it “not likely to be earned’’ incentives, based on stats that he didn’t achieve this season.
Gronk was a good sport this year for the Patriots, and worked hard to earn every penny and lead his team to the Super Bowl. But his relationship with the team could sour quickly if the Patriots don’t step up with a better contract offer.
Ben Volin can be reached at ben.volin@globe.com. Follow him on Twitter @BenVolin.



