Print      
Formation of society’s upper crust is part of what makes America work

Silpa Kovvali’s view (“Harvard’s toxic final clubs culture,’’ Opinion, May 13) is that Harvard fails to foster cross-class socialization. That could probably be said of the entire US educational system, starting with selective pre-K programs and continuing through prep schools and Ivy League colleges, so it runs much deeper than Harvard.

But Kovvali fails to acknowledge that the status-seeking that keeps this system humming is part of what makes America work. American philanthropy, which is unique on this planet, is driven in large part by a unique social mobility that enables the US self-made billionaire to rise from poverty to society in one generation.

For this impulse to drive the US economy, there needs to be a societal element. That’s where elitist institutions such as final clubs make a positive contribution. Much of Western literature, from Stendhal through Austen and onward, is preoccupied with describing how the bourgeois becomes a gentilhomme.

The president of Harvard, Drew Faust, realizes, I’m sure, that there is little she can do to change human nature.

Peter Foukal

Nahant