Print      
Birds are dying; USDA is to blame
Agency says it is poisoning starlings to control their population
By Billy Baker
Globe Staff

On a bitterly cold night two weeks ago, Vasiliy Burunov was standing outside his home in West Springfield when something strange caught his eye.

Across the street, Jim Mirolli was working on his van, and as Burunov watched his neighbor, a small bird fell from the large pine tree in Mirolli’s yard.

Burunov walked over, picked up the starling — which was still alive — and the two men theorized that the bird must have been freezing. Burunov took the bird inside his house to try to warm it up, and Mirolli returned to working on his van. A moment later, he heard a thump on the roof of the van. Another starling had fallen from the tree. This one was dead. Then came another. And another. Soon, there were about a dozen dead starlings on Mirolli’s lawn, and five more struggling for life in a box in his house.

“It felt like the end of the world,’’ Mirolli said. “I’m thinking ‘What’s going on here? Birds are dropping out of the sky.’ ’’

The birds were not freezing. They had been poisoned by biologists from the United States Department of Agriculture as a means of population control, a move that has stunned some residents in the area and enraged Richard Cohen, the mayor in neighboring Agawam, where the actual poisoning took place. He says the city was not notified that birds were being poisoned until after the fact.

“I’ve got a lot of consituents who are alarmed about why we didn’t tell them this was happening, and the reason is because we didn’t know,’’ Cohen said. “They’re worried about their pets, their children, their families, and that’s justifiable.’’

It turns out that the USDA has been poisoning starlings in Massachusetts for five years, in response to specific requests following damage issues caused by the aggressive non-native species. In Agawam, a USDA spokesperson said, the measure was in response to complaints of excess droppings threatening health and safety at an industrial site and at nearby residences. Birds were also poisoned in Belchertown and Ellington, Conn., where they were consuming livestock feed.

The birds were brought to the United States in 1890 by a German immigrant named Eugene Shieffelin, whose plan was to introduce into North America every bird mentioned in the works of William Shakespeare. Shieffelin imported 60 European starlings from England — they are mentioned just once by Shakespeare, in “Henry IV, Part I’’ — and released them in New York’s Central Park, where they thrived. Today, there are an estimated 200 million starlings in the United States.

Since their arrival, they have created all kinds of issues, from crowding out native species and spreading disease to damaging property and endangering aircraft, according to R. Andre Bell, a USDA spokesperson.

In 1960, an Eastern Air Lines plane plunged into Boston Harbor just after takeoff from Logan Airport, killing 62 people. Hundreds of dead starlings were found at the end of the runway, and authorities at the time postulated that the birds had flown into the air intakes of the engines, causing them to stall.

According to the USDA, the birds found in West Springfield were poisoned using a pesticide called DRC-1339, which is set out as bait and then observed by biologists, who will stop the treatment if other bird species arrive, or attempt to disperse them. The application site is prebaited using a special fat-based bait that is highly attractive to starlings but not to other songbirds.

The pesticide, often known as starlicide, is not considered harmful for a scavenging bird that eats or plays with a dead starling, according to Bell, who said research suggests a cat, owl, or other raptor would need to feed only on poisoned birds for several months to be affected.

Cohen, the Agawam mayor, has written to his congressional delegation, demanding a 30-day notification from the USDA for any future poisonings.

“I’m not a biologist or a chemist, and I don’t want to get into the moral and personal issues of what the USDA is doing, but I never heard any concerns about these birds being a nuisance. The first complaints I heard were about dead birds,’’ he said. “I represent the citizens and they are concerned and we need to know these things are happening so we can be transparent.’’

Billy Baker can be reached at billy.baker@globe.com.Follow him on Twitter @billy_baker.