WASHINGTON — Attorneys for the District of Columbia and Maryland argued in federal court Thursday that by conducting private business transactions with other states and foreign embassies, President Trump has violated the Constitution and raised questions about whether his loyalty could be bought.
‘‘By accepting emoluments, the president creates a constitutionally prohibited market for presidential influence,’’ said Steven Sullivan, an attorney representing Maryland Attorney General Brian E. Frosh, referring to the payments Trump’s company receives through its hotels and other businesses.
That, he said, ‘‘puts the state and the District in an intolerable dilemma, which is either pay to play’’ or risk that others might be paying to gain the president’s favor.
Thursday’s hearing, before US District Judge Peter J. Messitte in Greenbelt, Md., focused on two little-tested constitutional provisions: the ‘‘emoluments’’ clauses.
Written to stop officials of early America from being swayed by gifts, they bar the president from taking emoluments from either foreign governments or individual states.
The modern meaning of ‘‘emolument’’ is one of the things at issue: Does it cover things like payments for hotel rooms and banquet halls at Trump’s properties? Or should it cover only outright gifts to Trump, with no services rendered?
Thursday’s hearing was just the beginning of this legal fight — or, perhaps, the beginning of its end.
The Justice Department, representing Trump, has filed a motion to dismiss. In Thursday’s hearing, it asked Messitte to throw out the case on the grounds that neither the District nor Maryland has a legal right to sue Trump in the first place.
washington post

