Print      
Lesson from the Nassar case: listen
By Gina Scaramella

Perhaps the most incredible, this-cannot-possibly-be-true moment of the Larry Nassar case took place on Monday, when we learned that Michigan State University’s sports medicine clinic had been hounding 15-year-old Emma Ann Miller’s mother for payment of medical treatment Miller received from Nassar throughout 2016.

Nassar pleaded guilty last fall to multiple counts of sexual assault of patients, including Miller, while working as the team doctor for USA Gymnastics and running the clinic at Michigan State University, where he was also a faculty member. On Wednesday, he was sentenced to 40 to 175 years in prison. (In a separate case, Nassar pleaded guilty to child pornography charges.) Given the scores of victims — some of whom are using their platform as high-profile Olympic athletes to keep the media focused on the story — as well as the number of people who knew of Nassar’s abuse of athletes for at least two decades but did nothing to protect his patients, we will be talking about this case for years to come.

And we’ll probably never stop talking about the survivors’ extraordinary testimony. More than 150 gave compelling accounts of how not just Nassar’s actions, but also the actions of those who shielded him, have affected their lives. Three themes came up repeatedly in Judge Rosemarie Aquilina’s Michigan courtroom over the six days of testimony from survivors. They can be distilled into lessons for all of us — but most especially for institutional leaders who are grappling with reports of sexual abuse, or trying to implement prevention-based policies.

The first? Take allegations of sexual assault seriously. People rarely lie about being victims of sexual violence, while those who commit sexual assaults nearly always do. Multiple survivors have testified that they told officials with USA Gymnastics and MSU of Nassar’s abuse but were ignored. One was actually informed by a Title IX investigator who looked into her complaints about Nassar that she had misinterpreted an appropriate medical exam as a sexual assault because she lacked familiarity with osteopathic medicine. (In her complaint, the woman said that Nassar had become sexually aroused during the exam.)

Still others have explained that they never spoke up until Nassar was charged because they knew they would not be believed. “It took 37,000 pornographic images of children on his computer for people to believe that Nassar could do something like this, and you wonder why nobody wanted to speak up?’’ Bailey Lorencen testified.

Second, understand that the obligations of your business, school, or organization to employees, clients, customers, and members do not end when the offender has been fired. You must conduct a thorough audit of your operations to understand all of the areas affected by the offender’s behavior, and formulate a plan to repair the damage. This is something that MSU has stubbornly refused to do. As a result, the university learned, along with the rest of the world, that its medical billing department had been sending collection notices to Nassar’s victims when Emma Ann Miller announced, just seconds into her testimony, that her mother was “still getting billed for appointments where I was sexually assaulted.’’ (Within hours of Miller’s testimony, MSU announced that it would no longer bill Miller or other former patients of Nassar’s with an outstanding balance.)

Last, you must include survivors as you figure out how to move forward. A few days after Simone Biles, the most decorated gymnast in US history, tweeted out that she did not want to have to train for the 2020 Olympics at the official US gymnastics training camp in Texas where she had been abused by Nassar, USA Gymnastics announced that it was closing the ranch.

The move drew praise for being responsive to those abused by Nassar. But Olympian Aly Raisman, during her powerful testimony at Nassar’s sentencing hearing, showed that closing the ranch was anything but responsive. Not only had USA Gymnastics not consulted any survivors about its decision, but athletes were also literally training at the facility when the announcement was made, Raisman said, and none had been warned ahead of time.

If USA Gymnastics had included survivors in the decision-making process, the organization might have considered, rather than public relations, questions more relevant to athlete safety. They might have asked who should and who should not be welcome at any of USA Gymnastics’ training facilities. They might have discussed what other things USA Gymnastics should be doing to ensure the safety of athletes.

Survivors of sexual assault are forced to confront the past every day. They must train at the ranch, return to work, or go back to school. Traversing the spectrum from victim to survivor is no easy journey, and the worst thing you can offer a survivor is an empty promise while taking away options. All of us need sexual violence prevention that results in real change; survivors deserve it.

Gina Scaramella is the executive director of the Boston Area Rape Crisis Center.